Every attempt to “fight piracy” that isn’t “prosecute pirates” is just a backdoor to suppressing speech a government doesn’t like.
Any attempt to prosecute a pirate should assume they're innocent and have to prove otherwise. None of these allegation based stuff that they've had content therefore they're a pirate.<p>At this point I think all of us have already paid multiple times for the same license for the same content. My default assumption these days is that the pirates are the companies trying to once again remove access to a license I already had and trying to sell it to me once again.
There definitely needs to be reform and regulation on digital purchases. It's absurd that when you buy a piece of media you don't own access rights to that media perpetually. Further, it's absurd you can't give or lend access to your purchased media to others.<p>The same rules that apply to physical media should apply to digital. I should be able to sell a copy of my digital media on a second hand market or lend it to a friend or family member. Especially because the price of these purchases is identical to what these companies want to charge for physical media.
... trying to lease it to me, but making it sound like they're selling it.
Agreed that DNS isn't the place to act, but "prosecute pirates" too can be weaponized in so many ways. Today is a soccer match, tomorrow will be a Freudian slip during a live interview a politician or other prominent figure doesn't want to spread for more people to watch.
Back when the term "piracy" was being leveled against folks who shared their music on file sharing apps, Richard Stallman had an interesting point. "Pirates" are people who threaten and intimidate and kill and murder innocents, swinging in on ropes with their swords drawn to attack. How does that word apply to people who are basically just trying to help their neighbors listen to cool music?<p>The use of the word "piracy" to apply to folks who may or may not be civilly liable for copyright infringement is an attempt by already wealthy and powerful entrenched interests to improve to their bottom line.<p>TL;DR: That should be "sue potential copyright infringers", not "prosecute pirates."
The media companies aren't fighting piracy, they are enforcing market segmentation.
How do you prosecute a torrent stream with peers in five different countries?
The same way they already do? You go to those peers and prosecute them. They're not unidentifiable.<p>If the other countries don't cooperate, then you're fundamentally in the same problem space as if each of them was a full-on Russian website.
I don't think there is a legal way to do that in any way, shape or form without all the countries collectively agreeing on something. Individual countries may be able to get specific peers in their jurisdiction removed, but I think that's about it.
And the other side is the adtech companies shitting on users for decades.
This is well said. Too many people want to wink and let the pirates off easy. But that just encourages more piracy and harsher measures. If we want artists to be able to earn their living with their art, we need to give them the ability to be treated fairly by the public.
Perhaps copyright law should start treating the public more fairly first?<p>Piracy is mostly a self-created issue nowadays.
Observe the lesson of Netflix.<p>Access to a wide variety of stuff at a reasonable price. Big decline in piracy. Now everyone is trying to make their own streaming service to get a piece of the pie and they make exclusive content to make you choose their service. And we are back at the point where it's prohibitively expensive for most people to get what Netflix used to offer. Is it any surprise piracy went back up?<p>And the fundamental problem here is that companies want maximum profit and that's obtained when they make their offerings *just* good enough to get customers. If the customer is happy with the product that almost certainly means they could have charged more or provided less. Business has grown increasingly skilled at this game of just good enough.
I would add that the movies that are "bought" on services like Amazon, Apple, Sony, et al, have no warranty for suddenly being pulled and made unavailable to the buyer. In addition to many movies (e.g. Train Dreams) never being released on physical media so they couldn't be purchased in durable form even if one wanted to. I fully acknowledge these scenarios are covered in ToS, and are the prerogative of the property owner, but underscores the point - "is it any surprise that piracy has gone back up"?
Right. Just like with AI.
> If we want artists to be able to earn their living with their art, we need to give them the ability to be treated fairly by the public.<p>It appears that nowadays the front of the fight toward content censorship is in the live sports domain, ahead of music and movie industries. Artist were much less directly involved anyway than the companies exploiting their author rights.<p>Also, digital artists are now pushed out by AI.
I am all for people being honest about what piracy is and isn’t, but unless I am mistaken pretty much every study shows that artists/creators/etc. are minimally, if ever, harmed by piracy. I’m not sure I buy the argument that sometimes it even helps them, I think that’s always been rather anecdotal I haven’t seen any good evidence for it (I’m sure individual examples exist but you catch my drift). But yeah, I do believe it’s relatively neutral.
How is copyright meant to benefit artists when the copyright lasts until <i>after</i> their death?<p>Let's face it: for the content we are talking about here, the artists just have regular day jobs. They get <i>zero</i> residuals. The only thing at risk here is corporate profit.<p>Want artists to earn a living with their art? <i>Sponsor their Patreon.</i>
you can argue that stealing from Disney for example is more ethical then paying them
You can argue it, but you'd be wrong. If we grant for the sake of argument that it's unethical to pay Disney, then the ethical action is to <i>not consume their content</i>. "I still want this, but don't want to pay for it" is not an ethical stance.
It is absolutely an ethical stance. It might not be <i>your</i> ethical stance, but it's a self-consistent one. "Copyright should not exist." Or, alternatively, "Copyright should be much less strict than it is."<p>Law does not define ethics.
Not sure why you were downvoted<p>tbh I think you have to basically have a child's "wah, it's not fair" mindset to justify stealing movies and tv shows as some moral cause<p>That said, I do think fair use and IP law/copyright durations are improperly balanced towards "rightsholders" against the public interest/cultural benefits you'd get with a more permissive stance towards derivative works or things like showing a UFC fight in a bar without special licenses.<p>But that's different from "I should be able to watch the newest Star Wars without paying for it!"
I think after several 'lex Micky Mouse', that argument doesn't hold much ground anymore. Unjust laws must never be followed.
[dead]
is downloading and not watching them stealing at all? Because making a person to watch Disney is definitely not ethical...
"prosecute [unlicensed content holders]" sounds much less important than "prosecute pirates".. when we start calling things what they are, I might be more willing to listen.
That's a slippery slope to "laws are just a backdoor to suppressing people the government doesn't like"<p>Kinda a useless argument.<p>We have future trillion dollar companies that are industrial scale pirates
See also: Child abusers, terrorists, communists...<p>The cover art changes from time to time, but the song remains the same.
> Every attempt to “fight piracy” that isn’t “prosecute pirates” is just a backdoor to suppressing speech a government doesn’t like.<p>I'm afraid this has nothing to do with "suppressing speech" cliches. This is more straight forward than that: a judicial system is enforcing rules that are in place to benefit corporations even at the expense of everyone.<p>It just so happens that once the infrastructure is in place, it can be abused for other purposes.
<i>> This is more straight forward than that: a judicial system is enforcing rules that are in place to benefit corporations even at the expense of everyone.</i><p>To my eyes, that's precisely the government suppressing speech it doesn't like. Speech is so much more than just the modern political moment.
Didn't they already use this to block phone messengers during the riots?
> a judicial system is enforcing rules that are in place to benefit corporations even at the expense of everyone<p>In other words: business as usual?
Yeah but "prosecute pirates" is not feasible because a lot/most of them are located in jurisdictions that won't cooperate (Russia, China to name two).
We could shut down Internet access to them until they cooperate but that has a lot of other negative consequences and it seems piracy is a small price to pay in comparison.
Especially when Gabe Newell's statement is still correct. Piracy is a service problem, not a pricing problem. If the owner is unwilling to meet the demand for service, people will seek alternatives. Here the problem is the sports event broadcasters demanding their monopoly be respected.
<i>> Piracy is a service problem, not a pricing problem.</i><p>IDK, <i>some</i> piracy is a service problem, certainly. But pricing can also be a problem.<p>In my country, Formula 1 has decided the TV price that maximises their profits is about $350 a year. Possibly more, their pricing is very confusing. That's too high for me, so I don't watch it.<p>But setting a price that puts a bunch of customers off is a perfectly valid business strategy; presumably they think halving the price wouldn't double subscriber numbers.<p>(The customer service is also pretty weak)
That "solution" to piracy ultimately is just price discrimination/personalized pricing, where you sell media for a much lower or higher cost depending on someone's purchasing power and willingness to spend money for something.<p>Which is just going to piss more people off and create a new kind of "piracy" where you buy things through someone else.<p>To be honest I am kind of sick of hearing people justify not paying for something that isn't intended to be free and which someone else has to spend significant time/money to provide. There are a lot of adults with this mindset now.<p>It's not just a service problem lack of spending power. Some people are simply assholes and the only way to stop them from stealing or leaching off other people is to make them stop. Gabe Newell just doesn't say this because a lot of his audience are literally children/manchildren
I don’t think you’re off base here. Honestly, it seems like it’s best for there to be an equilibrium. By that, I mean, things are available for purchase at the price that’s believed to be optimal. And piracy is completely possible, but tricky and a little bit scary. This way, people who were never going to be willing or never going to be able to afford the expensive media can still get it, by trading larger amounts of their time. That hurts no one. But it’s still best for privacy not to be too trivially, easy and simple for the common man, so that the addressable market for the paid content remains big enough to actually sustain its creation.<p>Where we get into problems is when some company or industry deludes themselves into thinking they can make piracy impossible. Mostly what this seems to do is make the experience of the legitimate customers worse. e.g. HDCP, a pointless waste of time that hasn’t done anything to prevent piracy. And the wave we have seen lately of these futile, but disruptive attempts to “block piracy” at the DNS level.
I think at a societal level it would generally be better for those people to spend that extra marginal time/skills working for someone else to provide a useful marginal service, then spend the currency on the media they want, than to force them to waste time or make their computer insecure to get it for "free".<p>But I do agree that you simply cannot make piracy impossible, and that many (but not all!) of the approaches to doing so are generally boneheaded, including this one.<p>In this case it actually makes much more sense to do it at the IP / transit level because that's something sovereign countries can genuinely enforce on their physical territory and the ISPs operating within them. And yes, you could evade that with VPNs, and then governments can crack down on those too, or figure out how to control and limit them by making sure they have to pay global IP transit rates / enforce IP rights on pirated media served from IXPs in their borders. But that would require governments to know how the Internet works!
> spend that extra marginal time/skills working ... then spend<p>Yeah. Not really a bad proposition of what the responsible person would say to the unrepentant price-driven pirate. In my mental model, the most devoted pirates are teenagers, and people from countries with far lower per-capita GDP where they can't access the legal 'streaming' type options Westerners can due to both IP blocks and cost.<p>So, the "anti-piracy maximalists," if they succeeded in their impossible dream, would accomplish nearly zero incremental revenue, but they'd convert the whole Internet into a creepy, authoritarian, free-speech-hostile, anonymity-preventing surveillance state in the process, just to make sure some broke, foreign, or lazy people can't access certain entertainment products.
Note: My lazy ass was dictating. It kept hearing "piracy" as "privacy" and I missed fixing one sentence:<p>"best for privacy not to be too trivially, easy" -> "best for piracy not to be too trivially easy"<p>Serves me right for using Apple's abysmal STT.
Maybe it's true in some domains but definitely not in all.
For example my software is pretty easy to buy and run but it gets pirated by Chinese crackers a few days after every release. They then re-sell it for half the price.
That pushed us to not publish binaries anymore and go into cloud based model. It sucks because I liked the model of selling software that people can run locally but it is no longer feasible because of piracy.
I've been considered developing desktop apps for MacOS and releasing through their app store for this reason. The incentives just make it a much better customer base for distributing paid, local software than any other platform.<p>Then of course people can decompile it and rerelease it or jerry-rig it up for other platforms, but you can safely assume that will never eat in to your actual customer base of MacOS users buying desktop applications.
Have you done any research into who is running the pirate version?
Take the NBA as a prime example. They have their streaming NBA service... you can simply pay them monthly to view any game... but wait you gotta exclude games where the rights were sold to espn/amazon/nbc. all the GOOD games, then they also offer commercial free, but again, not for those networks. so to watch the games youre subjected to subscribing to 4 different products, and all the good games you must be subjected to ads as well.<p>And their product? basketball. This isn't some mindblowing piece or anything, its simply basketball.
> We could shut down Internet access to them until they cooperate<p>Is there a reason why the powers that be aren't squeezing the peering providers like they are with DNS? I suppose that DNS is a mostly a single point of failure rather than having to go to all the Internet Exchanges [0] in one's jurisdiction.<p>0. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Internet_exchange_points" rel="nofollow">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Internet_exchange_poin...</a>
That's being done in Spain right now and it's causing collateral damage because criminals and legit sites are sharing the same IP address. And the biggest provider refuses to unshare them.
I agree that this is the solution.<p>I'd also be very interested to hear Cloudflare's counterargument against it because it would actually put the bulk of enforcement on them.
> Yeah but "prosecute pirates" is not feasible because a lot/most of them are located in jurisdictions that won't cooperate (Russia, China to name two).<p>So what? Censoring the internet to appease copyright holders is worse than allowing unprosecutable piracy.<p>Rights holders could start by offering a better product than pirate sites, that’s how Steam managed to get game pirates to buy PC games.<p>But instead they charge you a monthly fee and then charge you again not to show ads, then they jack up the price and remove the ad-free option. If they weren’t so goddamn greedy people wouldn’t pirate as much content.
I am a right holder of software I created. You can buy it and download it. Pepole still sell cracked copies of it. How am I supposed to "offer a better product"? It's really easy to buy and download already.<p>>>But instead they charge you a monthly fee and then charge you again not to show ads, then they jack up the price and remove the ad-free option. If they weren’t so goddamn greedy people wouldn’t pirate as much content.<p>If you don't like it then don't buy it. What is your problem?
It's probably better for you not to watch it anyway. Why do you feel entitled to take something someone spent time and resources to create just because you don't like some aspects of it?
The two halves of your comment need to talk to each other.<p>It's pretty offensive for a service to be paid and then pause the content to shove in ads too. You offer a better product by <i>not doing that</i>. And people <i>should</i> loudly object, not just refuse to buy in the quietest way possible. Wanting a paid service to act like a paid service is not entitlement.
If they want to shut down Russian internet they should do that instead of beating around the bush.
I don't know if it is accurate or not but the quad9 statement takes some trouble to indicate that much pirate hosting is based in <i>Europe</i>.
They <i>could</i> also go for the <i>consuming</i> side. The people making use of the illegal content are local, so that should be fairly easy to address, right?
That sounds nice, but it isn't correct. A lot of piracy fights are civil in nature. If you sue somebody for infringing on your rights, you probably aren't trying to suppress speech.<p>When Quad9 fails to resolve malware and phishing sites without trying to get the bad guys punished, they aren't a tool of the government.<p>Are there some examples where a piracy prosecution was clearly trying to suppress speech?
Mainly as counterexamples. A federal judge decided that Diebold used DMCA “as a sword to suppress publication of embarrassing content” and held it liable for knowingly misrepresenting infringement (2003). Another judge decided that Scientology's primary motivation was to "stifle criticism and harass its critics" (1995).
The civil orders make ISP and DNS resolvers build techincal infrastructure for enabling censorship. Same for filtering access to content based on users age that require deanonymizing users.<p>This just opens the door for content censorship applied to other domains when governments shifts for the worse, beyond live sports or music/movies as the technical infrastructure is now deployed.
The only way to fight piracy is make the paid version a better experience. Still, downloading a movie is a better experience than trying to watch it legally. Because legally you need to either sign up for a streaming service or get a DVD. Both serious pains.<p>For instance, if there were a site that offered movie downloads for $2-5 per movie, I'd happily pay for it. No DRM of course. Why bother? Pirates already copy all the movies anyway. Hyperion does it for music. I've bought lots of MP3s there of classical music without any problems and it's a decent price.<p>But for movies, the paid experience is way worse.
Is it though? Most movies I'm only watching once. A rental is usually 4-6 USD, maybe more if it's very new. It's on my TV in 4k pretty soon after.<p>Piracy, I have to at least spend some time finding the torrent and getting it on my plex box. Then I have to wait for it to download and for Plex to scan.<p>I am more often using the legit channels these days because it's pretty convenient and I don't mind supporting those who made the content.
I’m not going to pay 4-6 USD for one viewing of a movie released decades ago. That’s absurd. For that price I should be able to actually own it (non revocable license). Which I can’t get real ownership even if I “buy” it, so piracy or physical media is the only option.
I don't disagree with your reasoning, but might I remind you that Blockbuster and the other rental companies of the 90s charged roughly the same amount for the same service, with less convenience because you had to pick up the movie, drop it off, etc... Whereas a YouTube rental lets you start whenever you want (within 30 days I think) and you just need to finish it within a few days of pressing play.<p>Most folks don't really care to own media. I'll "buy" a movie on YouTube or whatever if I know I'll watch it multiple times. If the company decides to revoke my license for whatever reason, well they're bastards for doing so, but then I'll resort to acquiring a DRM free version by whatever means necessary.
I'm definitely not trying to tell you every movie is worth what they're asking to rent it. I'm just saying it's not really a convenience issue imo.<p>I draw the line where it makes sense for me. All I'm saying is, every now and then when you're sitting down to watch a movie, consider renting it. ESPECIALLY if it's independent or newer or something like that. Or at least see what they're asking for it.<p>And hey, sometimes, if you rent it, don't quite finish it in the window or want to re-watch, the torrents will always be there.
I can tell from experience that it is. I know how to and and where to get games to pirate easily, for example, yet when I want to play something I do buy it on Steam or Gog regardless. Besides supporting the makers steam's infrastructure around (forums, guides, etc) them and Gog fixing many games for modern systems make it a good sell for me.
Using Ombi and some of the arrrs - it takes 5 minutes to get something from a request on your phone to plex. The ecosystem is really dialed in these days.
The other dimension is general distrust for rental media companies. Installing an app, creating an account, and making a transaction is giving up more than just 4-6 USD.
Finding what provider a movie is available on is usually a fun task. Maybe you can rent, maybe you can buy, maybe it's not available but it was last week, maybe you need to subscribe to a new service and set up an account.<p>Gabe Newell is correct - "Piracy is almost always a service problem and not a pricing problem." Even if I wanted to spend $200/month for all the streaming services, juggling all the apps is going to be more of a pain than going to Plex, where I can have everything I want to watch.
Well, I like to watch the classics several times.... I guess to each their own.
The current state of music streaming is great. I can sign up for whatever service I prefer (Spotify, Apple Music, Deezer, Tidal, etc.), and I get roughly the same catalog. I pay for the service that offers me the best features and compatibility. I choose Tidal because they have a robust API and excellent Chromecast support.<p>But for Movies and TV shows, you have to sign up for lots of services, each with their own largely-nonoverlapping catalogs. You can never sign up to watch everything; you have to sign up to watch some small portion of the content that is out there.<p>I can pay $11.99/month for access to virtually all music, but it'll cost me hundreds to access the same spectrum of TV shows and movies.<p>And if I want to watch just a single movie, why would I pay for a monthly subscription? It adds up fast!
And when a better experience means making it free without ads, it causes the business to fail.
I already gave the example of Hyperion music. They offer straight music downloads, no DRM, excellently-recorded classical music. And they don't have ads. I'm happy to pay for the music there.
[dead]
It's too late to "fight piracy", the ai companies have already consumed all the ip. If you don't care to prosecute commercial piracy, why bother with private individuals?
<a href="https://quad9.net/news/blog/au-revoir-france/" rel="nofollow">https://quad9.net/news/blog/au-revoir-france/</a><p><a href="https://blog.cloudflare.com/quad9-withdrawal-from-france/" rel="nofollow">https://blog.cloudflare.com/quad9-withdrawal-from-france/</a>
Is this a ridiculous decision by the French court because the judges lack competency, or is this a defensible position, ie judges correctly interpreting a ridiculous law?<p>I feel like that’s two very different situations and a lot of writing about bad court decisions such as this one don’t specify which it is. The courts don’t operate in a void, they try to apply the law.<p>So in other words, should our ire be directed at the courts or the lawmakers here?
The judge just applies the law which leaves implementation detail to the courts.<p>The main problem is the law that opens the door to wide scale censorship. The people to blame are representatives who voted the law, not the judges.
It's neither. Both the decision and the law makes sense. It's not a law we want, but it's one that makes sense given the purpose.
> Is this a ridiculous decision by the French court because the judges lack competency, or is this a defensible position, ie judges correctly interpreting a ridiculous law?<p>That's the thing, is there anyone who can disqualify an incompetent judge? Seems like there should be a process. It's like having a surgeon who doesn't understand basic anatomy in charge of performing surgery ("what's this squishy bit here, let's remove it, doesn't seem important").
No but I mean, which of the two is the case here? Is this like your surgeon removing a random squishy bit, or is this a competent decision about a stupid law?<p>I'm not asking how to disqualify the judges, I'm asking whether we should want to. It's easy to point the finger at the courts here, cause they made the decision, but if French law leaves no wiggle room then it's not the judges' fault.
They seem to rule like they simply do not understand like any of this works, in the most charitable interpretation of it<p>> but if French law leaves no wiggle room then it's not the judges' fault<p>That's a fair point. In different systems the judges may have more leeway than others. In US they have more leeway in "interpreting" the law in other places their hands may be more tied.
I think that this is turning into an issue involving a fundamental point of principle. DNS is simply a lookup service.<p>When you legislate to gag a lookup service, you are at the first stage of a very, very slippery slope towards a state of being that no European nation would ever want to be a part of again.
Dupe: <a href="https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50195959">https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50195959</a><p>Related: <a href="https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50538994">https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50538994</a>
Not a dupe as its an opinion piece by someone else, somewhat hilariously named<p>AL Smith, <a href="https://techstackups.com/authors/alsmith/" rel="nofollow">https://techstackups.com/authors/alsmith/</a><p>But the sites font looks like AI Smith, which I assumed was a cheeky way to say it was written by AI before looking up the authors bio.
> <i>"which I assumed was a cheeky way to say it was written by AI"</i><p>Well, it is written by AI. It's egregious.
yeah sorry this was an AI summary; I do find them useful for stuff like this when the information is all out there already but scattered in different places, but wasn't expecting it to get to front page!<p>Al(ice|en) Smith is indeed my agent and a reference to AI/Al looking similar in some fonts and agent smith from the matrix.
It is not a dupe
One thing is not well explained, if they can’t reliably detect french users, how can they leave france?
It mostly means having no legal entity or property in France that French courts can render judgments on. So they will geoblock as a basic compliance measure that doesn’t fully work but they avoid exposure by staying out of France.
They're Swiss (Zurich HQ), there is a lot of reciprocity between Switzerland and France when it comes to legal affairs, and one day Switzerland may want to join the EU so this isn't all that clear cut.
Living in Switzerland, I don't see the country joining the EU anytime soon if ever
Ever is a really long time. Sweden and Finland also never wanted to join NATO.
You don't have to be in the EU to have enforcement reciprocity with EU states.
You will, forcibly. Not today, but in the future.<p>I know, there is a lot of debate ongoing between the opponents. But you have one big rock around your neck:<p>UBS<p>And Im pretty sure, somewhen in the future, a bailout will be required - and this could be done then only with EZB, as SNB is too small, and you will "happily" join.
(and in that moment, there wont be any "international" white knights from abroad other than the EU/EZB, so you will be on board ;-)
I think it's partly about risk and what will get a prosecutor off your back and what a court might say "c'mon, they've done enough."<p>By geoblocking users in France, they've probably blocked at least 95% of French users from being able to access their services, if not closer to 99%. By not having any nexus in France, it does reduce their exposure. Yes, Switzerland and France might cooperate on things, but going after Quad9 via Switzerland would involve convincing Swiss authorities that a) France is correct enough that Switzerland should want to comply, b) the steps Quad9 has taken aren't enough, c) France should get to enforce this against a company that's completely extra-territorial.<p>Yes, Switzerland could still side with France, but it definitely makes France's job a lot harder. Even within a country, people often "forum shop" for a district or judge they think will be more favorable. Forcing France to get the Swiss to agree means getting a second party to also be so strict (or want to cave for diplomatic reasons).<p>As you say, it's definitely not clear cut. It does make it harder. It does reduce their risk. It makes it more likely that France will just declare victory and move on. Sometimes it's about making it not worth the fight. Would a French prosecutor's career be better served trying to get Switzerland to agree to essentially enforce French law worldwide against a non-profit? Especially when they are geoblocking most French users already - basically complying with the ruling as much as technology realistically allows? I think they'd probably find that their efforts would be better spent elsewhere. If Quad9 were still serving DNS queries from France, a prosecutor would have a much stronger reason to go after them in Switzerland. At this point, it just feels like a prosecutor would see it as a waste of time - like worrying about the cost of an array offset in a loop when you're doing a network call every loop, the network call's cost is just going to be so much greater and you should be spending your time on what matters. That said, people aren't always rational.<p>It doesn't get them in the clear for certain, but I think it does reduce the risk substantially.
There is no prosecutor, these are not matters of criminal law. These are civil cases. Under the Lugano Convention, Canal+ can ask Swiss courts to enforce French judgements. That is why they can't just ignore this order. The question would become, after they geoblock but French people use VPNs to continue to resolve these domains, can Canal+ get a Swiss court to give even a single solitary fuck about this crap French law? I'm skeptical and I think its unlikely they'll pursue it that far.
No offense, but if you know any Swiss, you would know that's unlikely
I know plenty of Swiss. Some of them are really happy being 'inside but outside' and others would see Switzerland as a model of how the EU could function if they set their mind to it but they realize this will not happen from the outside. But there are many areas where Switzerland and the EU are currently not very compatible. Time will tell, I think in the very long term it is inevitable, in my lifetime rather not. Even so, for practical things like legal issues like the one we are discussing I would not be surprised if a Swiss court was sympathetic. It is called the "Berne Convention" after all...
That actually illustrates something about online services. Often (if not most of the time) companies develop them without considering at all that they must still be able to abide by the national laws of each and every country their users/customers reside in... and that's hard. So when something happens the simple option is to geoblock the country.
That isn’t necessarily the case though. The only countries they MUST consider are ones with civil judgement treaties like the Lugano agreement that applies here. They don’t have to care about laws in Iran or Russia unless they have entities or assets there.
Ultimately it is a commercial and risk (commercial, legal, "bad outcomes") assessment. Even if in principle you should care about all the countries your service is accessible from, in practice you probably mostly care about countries that can come after you one way or another if you rub them the wrong way and countries where you have a non-negligible customer base (because countries can also block you and you lose business).<p>In the case of DNS, if you must customise by country it is probably not viable. So IMHO a unique global DNS service ultimately only "works" if countries don't care about it. As soon as they care the s hits the fan.
Isn't that the obvious thing to do
The technical matters don't matter much.<p>By saying they are not serving French users anymore, Quad9 will now be able to blame French users who are still accessing the service as circumventing their technical measures (if they ever enable some). Any court order from France will now get a standard answer "we do not serve France", so this should reduce legal costs.<p>Hopefully, the technical measures they will implement will impact service and get media coverage. I live in France.
Was wondering this to. The article explains why geoblocking France IP's isn't sufficient, then goes on to talk about how it will stop working for French users, without explaining how they do that other then based on IP
This way the French authorities have a much harder time holding Q9 liable for problems since they'll have no legal nexus within France. They won't be able to block all French users, but they won't get in trouble either.
Could Quad9 still get fined because they inevitably will handle French traffic sometimes?
The UK has had blocks in place for well over a decade, via ISPs - <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_websites_blocked_in_the_United_Kingdom" rel="nofollow">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_websites_blocked_in_th...</a><p>As far as I am aware, they government has never gone after DNS resolvers other than the big 5 ISPs.<p>I very much doubt it has had a major impact on piracy. Anecdotally I am aware that plenty of naive teenagers put themselves at risk using 'free' VPN services to circumvent the blocks.
One thing that drives me nuts is that your average European Government (look at Italy or France) is absolutely open to implementing draconian laws with borderline authoritarian censorship in order to save the profits of football leagues. It's absolute madness, and it's a reflection of the corruption and how football got too big and too powerful in Europe.<p>There's nothing bad with football, but having it take >90% of all sport revenues and mindshare is unhealthy
A self hosted recursive resolver fixes this. Have the courts take it up with ICANN
[dead]
Better yet, let's vote to keep people out of office who have stupid ideas like battling ICANN.
Better yet, let's vote politicians out of office <i>and</i> vote ICANN out of power too. They are not any better, e.g. they make money by spamming the root zone with gTLDs. Don't know who you'd replace it with - OpenNIC is just as bad.
(which they can't because ICANN is another government's department and governments not only see themselves, and that includes the smallest bureaucrat, as above their own law, they <i>certainly</i> see themselves as above other government's laws (whether or not that's the case, also see international treaties). So ICANN will tell French courts, literally, to go take it up with the president or congress)<p>But techies would do well to remember: ICANN isn't above the law because that makes technical sense.
The only pirates I have a problem with are the ones who make money off of their sharing (charging for access, ads on their site, etc).
While not on topic, this did make me curious how the scene will adapt in the next five to ten years. Storage has been abundant for trackers and pirates alike, but that just isn't the case anymore. People can't really just "seed" forever and add a few 6TB drives to their desktop or NAS, that's a $1k bill now.
Sure they can. It’s more expensive but not showstoppingly expensive. It is still far cheaper than it was historically when piracy was perhaps an even bigger force. Imagine what a few 6tb drives cost you in 2005. Now keep in mind today cd quality rips are still the same size as they were in 2005.
They could easily cut large chunks of storage usage with additional compression. Fit girl repacks already does it for many games, but more for people with lower internet bandwidth. A lot of video torrents are also still using h264 and could be significantly reduced in size with h265.
It costs money to make things. You think people should be able to freely bypass paying to use a product?
Sites aren’t hosted for free you know
Seems at least the "geoblocking is enough" part should be legislated at a higher level, even if you agree that dns blocking is the right solution. Long and expensive fights in every country to get that recognized are stupid.
Agree, totally wrong place. As far a namespace, my approach is to roll ur own.
As far as piracy, not my problem, agree with those who say as I'm sure some do that the ppl concerned with piracy are for the most part ones that bought some work product and are trynna own resell rights vs the actual creators.
Sigh.<p>This came up during the original "Les Kelly vs. Arriba Soft Corp." case in 2002[1] which was about the legality of "linking" on a web page.<p>The bottom line is that answering DNS queries, just like placing links on a web page, is protected speech.<p>If you doubt this:<p>It's easy to describe an (absurd) methodology of storing DNS records as human readable directions, in the form of anecdotes or sentences, which could then be parsed by a simple reader.<p>This is the reductio ad absurdum that I proposed in my public email exchange with Les Kelly[2] regarding the case:<p>"The idea that a web browser could simply read human english text descriptions of a pictures location on a web site, and then display it as if it were an inline link, is not that unbelievable."<p>... and the same is true with the DNS.<p>In 2026 it would be a trivial project to create a "DNS server" whose records were human readable, english statements and a client who could query them with similar.<p>After all these years, do I really have to create this ?<p>[1] <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelly_v._Arriba_Soft_Corp" rel="nofollow">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelly_v._Arriba_Soft_Corp</a>.<p>[2] <a href="https://www.kozubik.com/published/decisions_discussion.txt" rel="nofollow">https://www.kozubik.com/published/decisions_discussion.txt</a>
This article is an AI-generated (see Pangram) rehashing of Cloudflare's article yesterday :(
We need to move beyond copyright
Unaffordable costs for Quad9, or fighting for justice at the expense of others' deaths...<p>They seem to share a common pattern:<p>Knowing what is ‘right’, yet bringing wrongdoing forced onto others.<p>Better to go back to unknowing.
Having standards and not letting big players circumvent security measures is a good start though.
Am I the only one struggling to understand why "leaving France" is a viable legal option, but implementing a GeoIP block that applies to France only was deemed insufficient by the court? How do these situations differ legally?
Every place is the wrong place to "fight piracy".
The irony of this clearly AI-written piece starting out by referencing the need for "a long-form, well-reasoned statement of why France is taking the wrong path" is amusing
I don't think the US cares about piracy anymore now since those laws became inconvenient for training machine learning models, looks like the EU hasn't caught on yet.
They can follow-up by banning Google Maps so people wouldn't find their way to doing crime
So, the conclusion seems to be, if you live in France, run Unbound on your own hardware and give the sports mafia the middle finger?
Fighting piracy is the wrong fight to begin with
Agreed, but this won't deter companies from pressuring Cloudflare and the likes.<p>I hope to one day see a system loke DHT that are almost impossible to stop
All places are wrong places to fight piracy, I've been all about piracy when I was young, now I even have a season card, because I could follow my passion even when I didn't have the money to fight piracy, this year alone I've spent 2k for football, between season cards and merchandise, without considering the petrol to get to the stadium and parking, you want to fight piracy, fight piracy, alienate all the kids like I was to no follow their teams
the “ Why DNS blocking doesn't work” section is weak, replace dns with any other service and analyze it legally or ethically<p>> it’s just a pointer<p>every person in a chain is responsible for the result, forget about the specific case, if you assume a chain of service providers constitute a crime, then a lawful order for any provider to stop is reasonable, regardless of how they contribute. Especially considering that sometimes by how the systems are designed, there’s few actors that are identifiable and servable and accountable, a DNS is all that, so it attracts court orders to stop crime.<p>you wouldn’t accept this excuse by its own merits for an obviously criminal matter, so why use this argument just because you might consider that the law and order is unjust?<p>> “other providers do it”<p>the last time I remember hearing this argument was in school when the teacher scolded someone, it’s almost not worth explaining this one, but you have to start somewhere.<p>> “others will do it”<p>props here because this one I did not hear in primary school, but highschool. Again forget about the specific crime that you may or may not agree with, in general does it sound like a reasonable defense or excuse? “if I didn’t do it, others would have done” weak<p>for some reason piracy attracts a lot of people with lack of legal training to question procedural matters on the grounds that a crime is minor. Few are prepared to consider that several countries have themselves several judges in several courts all the way up to the supreme that agree on piracy and copyright rulings, somehow freethinker867 wants to weigh in on the subject as some sort of court higher than a national supreme court on the basis not of the whole cases (which would take ages to read and understand) but on some first principle grounds that piracy is not that bad and therefore the whole system must be wrong
you can take down private trackers in an afternoon, the truth is there are giant corporations that benefit from piracy too
Seriously, why can't I buy a textbook from India for $15 when the same sells for $200 in the USA?<p>Same company, but they greedy as fuck and want to use globalism to THEIR advantage, but throw a fit when us little guys try to.
Really disappointing situation.
France makes everyone sad these days. Macron nuked the
economy and fights the people on the street while amplifying
censorship laws. The guy is the ultimate turncoat - unfortunately
Le Pen will just implement ultranationalism 2.0 while appeasing
dictator Putin. Meanwhile France's economy is not going forward
anywhere - no real way for competition, rising debts dragging
the whole Eurozone down. I think all those lobbyists that ruin
a country, need to be held responsible, both with mandatory jail
time (no way to pay fine to escape) as well as seizure of all
illegal assets. The handwriting of what is going on is so clear.
Macron at least tried to make the difficult decisions (e.g. raising the retirement age) that would make France economically stable(r).<p>Their problem now is having to roll over state debt in a high-interest-rate environment. Their debt payments are going to balloon for the next ten+ years.<p>I’m strongly in favor of social welfare programs but you have to be able to pay for it. The unsustainable programs were not Macron’s doing and he tried to directly address them more than most. But it’s a political third rail in France so there wasn’t enough political will elsewhere.
No he didn't. He could simply order that everyone stops giving so much to billionaires, and there will be more money. The problem of upward movement of money is entirely caused by the government e.g. with land usage laws.
raising the retirement age is a bad decision? People already work to the bone and now they have to work more ....
“Macron nuked the economy” evidence? It’s not clear to me that anything here was policy based vs an accounting of what was already in place adapting to a changing world.
France’s economy was nuked long before Macron, when it promised excessive benefits to non workers relative to the country’s economic output and population growth.
It has absolutely preceded Macron. Long preceded. France spends 32.1% of GDP on social programs, up from 25% in 1990. This is 3rd highest rate out of 38 OECD countries, where the average is 21%. The public debt as % of GDP is 115%, up from 60% in 2000 and 37% in 1990. France is also near the top taxation rate as well.<p>It's extremely unlikely that France can improve their financial situation without reducing social program spending. And increasing spending on social programs is a terrible idea.
> And increasing spending on social programs is a terrible idea.<p>I mean yes, but also no. France doesn't have the same type of social problems that the USA has, france also has a smaller deficit that the USA.<p>France is a great place to live, the problem is affording that lifestyle.<p>The other problem is that because macron couldn't get the reforms passed (ie rasing retirement age) france is left with extreme left/right offering all sorts of shit (lowering retirement age, and or removing all income tax from anyone below 30)
>I mean yes, but also no. France doesn't have the same type of social problems that the USA has, france also has a smaller deficit that the USA.<p>France has a high deficit problem, a slow GDP growth problem, high social program spending, and high taxes. The question is if France has a problem, not if the USA has a bigger one.<p>>The other problem is that because macron couldn't get the reforms passed (ie rasing retirement age) france is left with extreme left/right offering all sorts of shit (lowering retirement age, and or removing all income tax from anyone below 30)<p>Well we may agree on some of this. Lowering retirement age and removing all income tax from anyone below 30 are not good ideas for France. And raising retirement age is more reasonable. The reforms did pass in 2023 and then they suspended it until 2028 due to all sorts of pressure. But if you are suggesting the reasonable actions are responsible for the more damaging ideas then I would disagree. Especially on the spending side, we already know this pressure existed. It's how France got in this position in the first place.
All you (as the government) have to do is reduce costs, mostly rent. If you set rent to zero then everyone has twice as much money. Non-workers may cry because they're not getting money for free any more, but you just tell them to get a job.
> In that thread, Quad9's CTO John Todd asked readers to write "a long-form, well-reasoned statement of why France is taking the wrong path", with plenty of sources, and to send it to policymakers.<p>I honestly can’t tell if this is a serious but hilariously misguided effort, or a deliberate attempt to fool people about what’s going on.<p>Judges and lawmakers didn’t do this because they misunderstood some technology issue. They did this because they got paid, or were appointed by people who got paid. They don’t give a rat’s ass about what the “correct” approach is in the opinion of tech bloggers.<p>If you want things to change fundamentally, you need money, leverage, or guns. Those in power have all three, and they are laughing at your attempts to educate them about what you think they should be doing. They’re not misunderstanding you. They’re not holding it wrong. This isn’t some random mistake born out of ignorance. Everything is going perfectly according to (their) plan. You’re barking up the wrong tree.
IANAL but I wonder is there a way for them to be required to read the statements? In that case the policymakers (that probably don't care about the technical side) will be flooded with work.<p>That would waste their time and money and make it less interesting to fight and showing them that it is a topic that impacts a lot of people (and angers a lot of people). That could work as leverage to get them to reconsider.<p>I can imagine them appealing and bringing a collection of these statements forward as evidence that 3rd party individuals largely oppose the decision but I don't know if that would work like that.
Quad9 wants people to think that this is government overreach, censorship, suppression of free speech, etc.<p>But what it is from an objective factual basis is a private company bringing litigation to civil court where Quad9 was the defendant, and Quad9 lost the case.<p>This is a dispute between private corporations with the government brought in as a civil law mediator.<p>From the perspective of the plaintiff, Quad9 was financially harming them, the court agreed, awarded damages, and gave orders to rectify that harm as a result.<p>This is not the French government telling Quad9 to do or not do something based on some kind of centralized speech censorship authority. This is Quad9 being upset that they lost their case and that they don't really want to comply with court order, so like a deadbeat ex refusing to pay child support or take care of Timmy 3 days a week, they're skipping town so they can avoid both options.
But the French government wrote the laws that the court used to decide the case, and could theoretically change the law if necessary.
That's all part of the government though. It's absolutely the government telling Quad9 what to do.
Shhh, don't give them any clues. Have them block dns resolvers ;-)
Oh but my friend, this is Europe, where we strive to be above such primitive dealings (while getting absolutely crushed by everyone who doesn’t…).
[flagged]
[dead]
It’s insane to me that they found a legal way to prevent the distribution of copyrighted material via DNS. Why isn’t ChatGPT.com blacklisted? I can ask for a verbatim copy of any book and get it 1:1 too?
Clearly piracy but somehow tolerated
It's known that they will block DNS records of piracy sites from a ton of years. Of course one user can just change the DNS, or even configure DNS over TLS/HTTPS, but 99% of the users doesn't know how to do so, and they use the default DNS server that the ISP provides, hence blocking piracy sites by simply pointing DNS records to a scary page that informs that piracy is a crime etc is far more simpler than blocking actual IP traffic (yes, they tried to so so in my country, Italy, recently, the effect was that they ended up blocking stuff like Google Drive so they gave up I think on the idea).<p>And yes of course in the reality the piracy site will just open under another DNS name and we know that, their goal is based on the assumption that it takes time and that if they block stuff right before an important football match (it's done for that, they only care about football because football clubs lobby the politics and they have big money, whatever else you can pirate and they don't give a fuck) the users doesn't have time to search the match on another domain or so and thus they will end paying 30 or 40 euros for Sky/DAZN/etc that of course it's not even true.
I'll give you one more: Ask chatgpt to do a DNS lookup of some piracy site via the webchat (It will run on some VM in a datacenter in USA and return accurate results)
I don't think you can?
Astra actually pretty regularly offers me hyperlinks to PDF's hosted on pirate sites, which I didn't even request. It's very eager to help, or something.<p>(API version, if it makes a difference).
I just tried to get some books from ChatGPT and it never offered me downloads or anything.
What do you prompt it ?
Why is it insane?<p>It's well known that EU is a very regulated place, with strong protections laws for everything.
John Todd, American, using the Switzerland ("The terrorist's favorite bankers / FIFA safe haven") scam not being able to offer his service to French people is supposed to make a mark? Why then does NextDNS (also based in France, and a much much better service) not cry on the Internet like American Johnny?
Ai dr