8 comments

  • FinnKuhn17 minutes ago
    The US did it with TikTok, so why shouldn't the EU also do it for TikTok, Instagram, FaceBook, etc.
  • vinni218 minutes ago
    Previous discussion <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=50549548">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=50549548</a>
  • amelius13 minutes ago
    Meanwhile data brokers exist, and can have Chinese owners.<p>They should address user tracking more broadly.
  • nonethewiser10 minutes ago
    OK so I have no problem with the initiative.<p>But let&#x27;s clarify something here:<p>&gt;Both officials pointed to the uncertainty surrounding the Chinese government’s potential access to European user data, given ByteDance’s origins.<p>This is fully protected by GDPR already. In theory. In practice GDPR cannot and has not stopped it.
  • ihsw32 minutes ago
    [dead]
  • theplumber23 minutes ago
    Then Facebook, YouTube and instagram. It’s time “take back control”!
  • ratelimitsteve21 minutes ago
    given that america just extorted it from the chinese, is the idea that every political unit of sufficient size just have its own tiktok where users can be protected from that dastardly foreign propaganda and only exposed to wholesome, local, pre-approved truth?
    • lenerdenator8 minutes ago
      That&#x27;s how China works, why not the West?<p>Try using Google&#x27;s services like YouTube, or Facebook in China without a VPN. Hell, we don&#x27;t even get the same TikTok that their citizens get. They were very careful to make sure that Western influences didn&#x27;t find their way over via social media.
      • f6v5 minutes ago
        Ok, so are we going to live just like in China minus affordable rent, manufacturing jobs, frontier AI, high-speed rail, good food, etc.? It&#x27;s a hard sell if you start employing whataboutism.
        • lenerdenator0 minutes ago
          Turnabout is fair play.<p>Take up the rest with your elected leaders.<p>You&#x27;ll also notice that there&#x27;s no real effort to do this with services hosted outside of China. It&#x27;s almost like the PRC has a long and storied history of hacking Western targets and they&#x27;ve earned a reputation as a result.
    • hsuduebc22 minutes ago
      Or, and I know this is a rather radical idea, maybe you don&#x27;t want foreign powers with a clear interest in destabilizing your society and influencing your politics to have free rein over one of your largest social media platforms.<p>But sure, let&#x27;s pretend the only two options are unrestricted foreign influence or government-approved truth.
  • abdusco22 minutes ago
    Is this another attempt at suppressing pro-Palestine speech?
    • adamors16 minutes ago
      Unknown actors on Tiktok heavily influenced the presidential elections in Romania[1], catapulting a virtual unknown candidate to the winner of the first round. Elections were then annulled.<p>Possible Germans are worried about AfD winning elections with similar methods.<p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;ec.europa.eu&#x2F;commission&#x2F;presscorner&#x2F;detail&#x2F;en&#x2F;ip_24_6487" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;ec.europa.eu&#x2F;commission&#x2F;presscorner&#x2F;detail&#x2F;en&#x2F;ip_24_...</a>
      • f6v7 minutes ago
        &gt; Unknown actors on Tiktok heavily influenced the presidential elections in Romania[1]<p>Are you like honestly taking this at face value? Dig deeper in all the declassified report and you&#x27;ll find that all the evidence of foreign interference is very very weak. We&#x27;d live in an extremely unpleasant world if you could convict someone of a serious crime using the same standard of evidence.<p>&gt; catapulting a virtual unknown candidate to the winner of the first round<p>It&#x27;s not illegal to do that and annulling elections based just on that is authoritarian. Again, no evidence the social media campaigns were financed by foreign governments.
        • Forgeties791 minute ago
          &gt; Dig deeper in all the declassified report<p>I can’t stand this cryptic “do your own research” crap. What “declassified report”? What are we digging for? What are you talking about specifically?
      • Kenji13 minutes ago
        [dead]
    • ratelimitsteve20 minutes ago
      as a politics wonk from the US I&#x27;m finding out that just about everything is either directly about suppressing pro-Palestine speech or its about generating a profit and then using a percentage of that profit to suppress pro-Palestine speech.
      • TFNA8 minutes ago
        As a politics wonk, you should be aware that this push against social media predates October 7, which is ultimately what sparked the current level of strident pro-Palestinian speech; before that, protest for Palestine was (though perennial) at a low background level and no one would have viewed it as socially destabilizing.
    • hsuduebc220 minutes ago
      [dead]