5 comments

  • hackermailman28 minutes ago
    This article is about who the author wants to hire for their newly funded AI games&#x2F;creativity lab. They want post-docs and grad students who can write a paper like a compelling story which is something I&#x27;ve heard Robert Harper at CMU say that there needs to be a hook to grab the reader and build to a satisfying climactic finding like you are writing for entertainment trying to spark ideas in the mind of the reader. These are the papers that are good and end up in conferences or selected for publications and this new department needs early wins probably to keep the funding going.<p>Then these candidates need to have a personal style in their research taste that stands out in their prior work like an artist would have. There&#x27;s a bunch of warnings that feeding prompts to some AI agent and calling it a day won&#x27;t cut it as he expects hard work. The candidate also needs to have breadth so they can identify symmetries or transfer knowledge from areas outside their specialty.<p>The rest is then a sort of apology where one dances around saying they didn&#x27;t really mean you can&#x27;t do this or that and to clear up any misconceptions but really they are saying you aren&#x27;t getting hired if you don&#x27;t have everything I just listed. It would have been easier if they simply said that without the many extra paragraphs.
    • dapperdrake22 minutes ago
      Larry McEnerney has two excellent videos about how to make written text readable. Iterate on it a.k.a. editing until it goes with the grain of the reader rather than the grain of the writer. Worth re-watching.
  • libraryofbabel1 hour ago
    I would give young researchers this to read instead; physicist Antoine Tilloy’s <i>The Short Age of Dragon Riders</i> that just came out a few days ago: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;atilloy.com&#x2F;2026&#x2F;11&#x2F;16&#x2F;the-short-age-of-dragon-riders&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;atilloy.com&#x2F;2026&#x2F;11&#x2F;16&#x2F;the-short-age-of-dragon-rider...</a><p>It&#x27;s not pleasant and comforting to read, but it&#x27;s more direct and honest, and much better written, than this.
    • skew-aberration15 minutes ago
      Thanks for the link, but I think the author is falling into the exact trap he is calling out - guiding his decision making by ego rather than what&#x27;s best for mankind.<p>&gt; I have always been a techno-optimist absolutist. It would be a betrayal to flip now that the wave of progress touches my craft.<p>AI touches every craft, not only yours, and therefore the grief you feel is more or less universal. To disregard it because it contradicts some sense you have of your own identity is dishonest.<p>&gt; As a result, he concludes, his main value for society lies in showing how far the human mind can be pushed with sustained effort and dedication ... Machines may progress to the point where this view (which I find self-serving) is the only reasonable one.<p>Humankind ought to be self-serving! There&#x27;s no point in making ourselves suffer for the benefit of machines.
    • Dzugaru53 minutes ago
      &gt; As of November 2026, the best public models still lack research taste.<p>Yes, undeniably, and not only in research.<p>&gt; Thanks to reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards (RLVR), models can improve simply by solving new tasks, and are in no way bound by human intelligence.<p>By what mechanism RLVR will make them acquire the &quot;taste&quot;?<p>This is always seems to be brushed off, while not at all obvious thing? Or I dont get something? RL has been tried for decades - it&#x27;s very sample inefficient and has been made to work in relatively simple domains like Go only recently. Why do we think language statistical model married to RL is not merely a good heuristic for it?<p>Are there some works I can read about this?
      • skew-aberration13 minutes ago
        Resource constraints, in my opinion. If it the AI is rewarded for shorter, neater solutions that generalize well to similar problems, then it will converge on a good sense of taste.
      • the847223 minutes ago
        &gt; By what mechanism RLVR will make them acquire the &quot;taste&quot;?<p>Maybe additional reward metrics? E.g. did a change make followup-tasks (performed by a separate instance) easier or more difficult, how many tokens does a judge-model need to understand and verify the produced artifact, etc.
    • CamperBob223 minutes ago
      That&#x27;s a really nice piece of work, and not just because it mirrors my opinion 100%. :-P Thanks for the link.
    • p11p42 minutes ago
      Excellent link, and a realist&#x27;s view of what is actually happening in the field compared to the blather posted by OP. Sorry to that prof, but you&#x27;re going to do your students a disservice if you serve them weak platitudes. Pangloss resurrected!
    • ViscountPenguin1 hour ago
      Thanks for the essay link, this has to be one of the most level headed things I&#x27;ve read about physics&#x2F;maths recently. I think this is pretty much the only thing I&#x27;ve read which acknowledges that results are fundamentally the thing that matters, and that society doesn&#x27;t fund mathematicians as a sort of Wagyu beef class of academic who&#x27;s role is just to enjoy themselves with interesting structures for the secondhand enjoyment of the public. Hopefully the dragon gets us lots of useful maths and physics, and not just copious paperclips.
  • justinnk1 hour ago
    The “understanding gap“ seems like a useful concept and puts a word on something I also noticed when using LLMs. You can sort of do some „speculative research“ now, where you let the LLM accelerate your work by filling in knowledge gaps, but only up until a certain point where you then have to catch up on the missing pieces by yourself to go further.<p>Also overall, the points mentioned seem like useful advice in these uncertain times where (young) researchers try to adapt to this technology.
  • ijuz59 minutes ago
    My advice to young researchers would be: don&#x27;t be a young researcher, use your smarts and make money.<p>(Yes, I have a PhD, and likely it was worth it for me, but I think the world is now moving too fast. Also an academic researcher would likely not have access to enough tokens and s lot of research wont be possible for them.)
  • 0c3ca832 hours ago
    There&#x27;s a lot of blather and not much advice.