16 comments

  • andrewla34 minutes ago
    I can&#x27;t read the article itself (or maybe listen to it? Hard to see what this page actually is). I read Harvard&#x27;s summary [1] of the article. The preprint is also available [2]<p>One thing to note is that the framing &quot;Just 400 US Data Centers&quot; makes it seem like 400 out of the gazillion data centers use this much electricity, but the original research seems to be that they found exactly 403 &quot;Hyperscale Data Centers&quot; and evaluated them.<p>The framing is technically correct (since there exist non-hyperscale data centers) but is clearly intended to be deceptive.<p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;hsph.harvard.edu&#x2F;news&#x2F;hyperscale-data-centers-energy-consumption-carbon-emissions-newly-estimated-by-re" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;hsph.harvard.edu&#x2F;news&#x2F;hyperscale-data-centers-energy...</a><p>[2] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;arxiv.org&#x2F;pdf&#x2F;2606.05420" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;arxiv.org&#x2F;pdf&#x2F;2606.05420</a>
    • qwe----325 minutes ago
      Also note like just the top 10 steel plants equal michigan as well...
      • ApolloFortyNine6 minutes ago
        There&#x27;s plenty of other industries that use lots of power as well, it seems some journalist managed to find a state that enough people see as &#x27;big&#x27; without enough of those industries to make the comparison look &#x27;fair&#x27;.<p>&gt;The team then modeled these facilities’ energy use in a variety of scenarios and calculated the energy mix of the regional grids to estimate individual facilities’ carbon emissions.<p>So is it just made up? The facilities energy usage that is?
      • peterabbitcook10 minutes ago
        Step 1: aggregate property x of “thing 1”<p>Step 2: find “thing 2” with property x closest to (result of Step 1) &amp;&amp; x &lt;= (result of Step 1)<p>Step 3: Write clickbait.<p>Optional: Publish some permutations - resample list of “thing 1” to yield min(number of “thing 1”) matching “thing 2” for each “thing 2” in list
    • unrented797722 minutes ago
      If the framing were &quot;top 400 datacenters use more electricity than Michigan&quot; would you still call it deceptive?<p>The point still stands that 400 of the gazillion datacenters in the US use more energy than the entire population and industry of an entire state. That&#x27;s a ridiculous amount of energy to pour into <i>any</i> number of datacenters.
    • undersuit14 minutes ago
      &gt;&quot;Just 400 US Data Centers&quot; makes it seem like 400 out of the gazillion data centers use this much electricity, but the original research seems to be that they found exactly 403 &quot;Hyperscale Data Centers&quot; and evaluated them.<p>I would assume you wouldn&#x27;t select the 400 smallest data centers and 400 random data centers would be weird to write an article about, so I defaulted to thinking the 400 largest(with available data). Was this assumption wrong? Where is the deception? Is it Michigan?
  • MOARDONGZPLZ0 minutes ago
    These topics are always contentious because you have a huge portion of HN whose livelihood depends on AI slop producing data centers, so they will refuse to recognize any negative externalities, or somehow say our environmental degradation is worth the cost, or simply hand wave it.
  • mvkel12 minutes ago
    The cherry-picking of the headline alone makes me not give the article any leash.<p>&quot;Just the McDonaldses in New York City use more electricity than North Dakota&quot;
  • bradleybuda1 hour ago
    The GDP of Michigan is $734B. The combined cloud computing revenues of Google, AWS, and Microsoft (which make up a large fraction of this datacenter work, though not all of it) are $290B. So yes, we should expect the power usage of these things to be in the same order of magnitude.
    • missedthecue1 hour ago
      Why calculate the cloud computing revenues and not the economic activity facilitated by the existence of cloud computing? You&#x27;re measuring multiple orders of economic activity by using Michigan GDP but only one order using google, aws, and msft cloud revs.
    • coryrc30 minutes ago
      We&#x27;re also not counting the petroleum powering the cars everyone is driving and the natural gas used as the primary source of building heat.<p>Electricity is useful for so many things, but it&#x27;s not needed in huge amounts in an ordinary Michigander&#x27;s life today. I wish they&#x27;d switch to EVs and heat pumps though, but electric rates make the latter cost more (EVs are cheaper).
      • bluGill23 minutes ago
        Michigan should install heat pumps. However it gets cold enough that a heat pump will not work for several days every winter (and even more nights), so while heat pumps will help they still need something and natural gas ends up our best bet...
    • shimman1 hour ago
      No, I wouldn&#x27;t expect that at all. Google, AWS, and MSFT do not care about helping society. They do not care about making sure children get a good public education. They do not care that workers are treated with dignity. These three can&#x27;t even bother to hire Americans for jobs in America. They just care about making money.<p>The state of Michigan provides more value for humanity than those three companies easily.<p>In fact we should explicitly tax those companies to provide free public school lunches, universal childcare, and universal college&#x2F;secondary&#x2F;vocational training programs.<p>For fun, look at what these three companies are explicitly paying for their data center build out and look at the cost of what it would cost to provide every American school child free lunch.<p>These companies are sick and should be justly destroyed.
      • bluedino1 hour ago
        &gt; These three can&#x27;t even bother to hire Americans for jobs in America. They just care about making money.<p>Are you talking about the auto companies?
      • jayGlow24 minutes ago
        we already tax these companies besides that the US spends on average around $17,500 annually per student among the highest in the world. How much more would we have to spend to provide free lunches for everyone? is there any guarantees that if we increased taxes we would actually solve these issues?
      • richwater1 hour ago
        &gt; should be justly destroyed<p>Ah, the truth emerges. The smokescreen about taxes, appeal to emotion, etc are all just rooted in that you want to seize and destroy companies you personally disagree of.
        • Computer042 minutes ago
          Who’s side are you on? Seizing and destroying is the peaceful option that will be presented.
  • renehsz46 minutes ago
    Datacenter power consumption wouldn&#x27;t be an issue if that power came from local renewable sources.<p>Unfortunately, the gas-fired turbines that are being built now feel like quite a regression. Or the additional load on the public grid, which in some places barely has any spare capacity left.<p>It&#x27;s not an unsolvable problem though. A sustainable hyperscale datacenter can be built. There just isn&#x27;t enough of an incentive as long as buying gas and polluting the air is cheaper (because the cost of both is externalized on society)
    • WarmWash12 minutes ago
      &gt;Datacenter power consumption wouldn&#x27;t be an issue if...<p>...they didn&#x27;t use them for AI.<p>The panic over DC&#x27;s has nothing to do with DC&#x27;s. It&#x27;s entirely about fear around AI and knee-capping AI progress. It&#x27;s like when conservatives suddenly care about native grasshoppers when they find out a solar farm is gonna be put on the land. You&#x27;re totally whiffing if you think they actually care about the grasshoppers.
  • djeastm1 hour ago
    Somewhat related: Data centers used 22 percent of Ireland&#x27;s metered electricity in 2024, up from 5 percent in 2015.<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.cso.ie&#x2F;en&#x2F;releasesandpublications&#x2F;ep&#x2F;p-dcmec&#x2F;datacentresmeteredelectricityconsumption2024&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.cso.ie&#x2F;en&#x2F;releasesandpublications&#x2F;ep&#x2F;p-dcmec&#x2F;dat...</a>
    • cjaackie55 minutes ago
      there’s a good reason for this and it relates to ireland and US corporate tax laws. Basically the rules changed for corps to move hqs there , and instead they needed to prove “economic substance” in ireland to establish EU hqs, which for tech companies meant data center builds.
  • Goodliff1 hour ago
    I work in AI, but this is obviously not sustainable unless renewable energy is used.<p>But according to AI Multiple:<p>Globally, only about 22% to 27% of the actual electricity consumed by AI and data center facilities comes directly from renewable energy sources like solar, wind, and hydropower.<p>They recommend the obvious, &quot;Prioritize inference efficiency over training efficiency&quot; since most power is used for inference now.<p>They reference research that shows that over 80% of AI compute is now used for inference.<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;aimultiple.com&#x2F;ai-energy-consumption" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;aimultiple.com&#x2F;ai-energy-consumption</a>
    • nsoam22 minutes ago
      Your message makes a lot of unsubstantiated assumptions.
    • j4558 minutes ago
      There is one more thing to consider - have our phones and software not become more efficient with computational power and battery life?<p>I don&#x27;t see that referenced anywhere often enough in the AI datacenter swirling.<p>It&#x27;s like saying mobile phones from the 1990&#x27;s would never become more efficient, nor software, nor chips.
      • scottLobster48 minutes ago
        Most of those efficiency gains came from shrinking transistors, and we&#x27;ve already hit the physical limits of Moore&#x27;s Law with atomic-scale transistors.<p>That&#x27;s not to say there aren&#x27;t more efficiency gains to be found, but the low-hanging fruit has been thoroughly picked.
    • mw88849 minutes ago
      &quot;Work in AI&quot; is one of those vague claims that could mean you work in a field relevant to the topic at hand, infrastructure, or that you simply use AI a lot at work. If your role was the more relevant one, one&#x27;d expect you to claim it specifically.<p>Your point is so basic it requires no expertise to reason about, however, anyways.
  • maerF0x027 minutes ago
    The demand creates incentive for people to add capacity to the grid. IMO what&#x27;s really needed is a combination of capital to invest into the grid plus incentives for the public to use less. (Eg: allow DCs to pay marginal bids &#x2F; $ to those who voluntarily reduce their usage. Allow a DC to pay me, say, $10 to free up $10 worth of marginal electricity usage, they effectively pay double the market rate and I have a benefit from DCs)
  • smallerize1 hour ago
    What I want to know is - what are they all doing all the time?
    • phoronixrly25 minutes ago
      Busy with inference for all the LLMs shoved into everything against users&#x27; wishes?
    • jakwnd51 minutes ago
      Hold on I&#x27;ll ask chatgpt.<p>Every google now comes with an AI answer too.
  • ck214 minutes ago
    I do not understand how &quot;AI&quot; can be profitable, it doesn&#x27;t make sense<p>even the expensive hardware has to be replaced every few years
  • AuthAuth47 minutes ago
    put that in a number i can understand like chinese steel plants or bitcoin mining
  • j4558 minutes ago
    I wish we could see datacenters as a percentage of other industries and how much electricity they use.
  • sciencesama7 minutes ago
    wait till one datacenter can take all that electricity
  • Silamoth1 hour ago
    Always good to see more hard data on this topic! I’d be curious to play with their dataset. I toyed around with doing some data center research a couple months ago. My vision was to compare data center counts and population densities near data centers built before and after the dawn of LLMs. And do some other stuff. But I had trouble finding reliable data on where data centers are located (some lists exist, but they’re not perfect, so I was doing manual validation) and when they were built (permitting and whatnot provided decent bounds). In the end, there was too much manual work. I didn’t feel like doing that all weekend for several weekends in a row, and I have a day job to worry about during the week. Though this might be motivation to look back at this and do some automation…<p>Regarding the actual result, I’m appalled but not surprised (though obviously it’s good to have concrete data). We environmentalists having been raising this concern for at least a year. More people are catching on - this seems to have helped the Blue Wave this election season. But a lot of tech bros still don’t get it, particularly here on HN. Maybe this will help change some minds.
  • spicyusername42 minutes ago
    And how much would we expect that number to be? I suspect nearly everyone is sufficiently ignorant about both datacenters and Michigan that they have no clue.<p>Useless rage baiting.
  • luckydata1 hour ago
    &quot;just&quot;?
    • honeycrispy47 minutes ago
      400 data centers are using more power than what 10 million people use to power their lives.<p>What do you mean &quot;just&quot;?
      • rwz40 minutes ago
        400 data centers probably serve a lot more than 10 million people though.
      • qwe----326 minutes ago
        Just 10 steel plants = michigan, how does that make you feel inside?
        • galleywest2007 minutes ago
          That steel plant employs far more people and produces a tangible good that the average person is impacted by more so than AI.