2 comments

  • codethief10 minutes ago
    Oof, these are devastating results. I have always been hesitant to put too much trust in TPM chips and have preferred choosing long passphrases instead of short PINs, and now I know why.
  • cwerling1 day ago
    Author here. Short version:<p>Windows Hello PINs are often just 4-6 digits. What makes that safe is the TPM&#x27;s lockout: after 32 wrong guesses, one try every 10 minutes. On most PCs the TPM is a firmware TPM inside the CPU (AMD PSP, Intel CSME, Pluton), which keeps its state, including the failed-attempt counter, encrypted on the external SPI flash. Encryption doesn&#x27;t stop replay: restore an old copy and the TPM forgets your failed guesses.<p>- 4-digit Windows Hello PIN: 40 hours instead of 69 days<p>- 6-digit BitLocker TPM+PIN: 20 days instead of 19 years<p>Affected:<p>- All AMD systems we know of. Without RPMC (JEDEC&#x27;s secure counters in the flash chip) AMD doesn&#x27;t detect rollbacks at all. With RPMC, AMD never verifies counter increments, so our Pi Pico based interposer just suppresses them.<p>- Systems with Winbond RPMC flash, including Intel: voltage glitching leaks the RPMC key, so the interposer can forge counters.<p>It&#x27;s a physical attack (stolen laptop, evil maid): you need to open the device and get at the flash chip.<p>We told AMD in February. It could fix this in firmware but hasn&#x27;t committed to a fix. The key leak needs a Winbond hardware revision; Winbond hasn&#x27;t told us it will do one.<p>Until then: treat your PIN like a password, or use at least a 6-digit Hello PIN and an 8-digit BitLocker PIN if numeric only.<p>Presenting at ACM CCS tomorrow, happy to answer questions here.
    • layer81 hour ago
      I want a TV show about the evil maid scenario.