Habermas talks a lot about the coffeehouses in his "The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere" -- how they changed the way society functioned, and politics was discussed and formed by them.<p>```
However much the Tischgesellschaften, salons, and coffee houses may have differed in the size and composition of their publics, the style of their proceedings, the climate of their debates, and their topical orientations, they all organized discussion among private people that tended to be ongoing; hence they had a number of institutional criteria in common. First, they preserved a kind of social intercourse that, far from presupposing the equality of status, disregarded status altogether. The tendency replaced the celebration of rank with a tact befitting equals. The parity on whose basis alone the authority of the better argument could assert itself against that of social hierarchy and in the end can carry the day meant, in the thought of the day, the parity of ‘common humanity’ (‘bloss Menschliche‘). Les hommes, private gentlemen, or die Privatleute made up the public not just in the sense that power and prestige of public office were held in suspense; economic dependencies also in principle had no influence. Laws of the market were suspended as were laws of the state. Not that this idea of the public was actually realized in earnest in the coffee houses, the salons, and the societies; but as an idea it had become institutionalized and thereby stated as an objective claim. If not realized, it was at least consequential.
```
Not at all equivalent to today’s coffee shops:<p>> The social impact of coffeehouse culture shows most clearly when juxtaposed
with earlier social norms. As Cowan (2005, pp. 101–105, 112) explains, coffeehouses,
rather than alcohol-centered public houses, became key venues for elite exchange. In
early seventeenth-century England, the virtuosi (natural philosophers and scholars)
tended to gather in aristocratic great houses, where interactions were formal and
exclusive. Coffeehouses, by contrast, encouraged informal, cross-class dialogue and,
as such, challenged traditional pathways to intellectual recognition. For less wealthy
aspiring virtuosi, coffeehouses provided unprecedented access to information and
social networks.<p>> <i>That access mattered more than the drink…</i><p>HN itself is probably filling that function to a degree.
Shame that cafes nowadays don't really (seem to) result in this form of conversation and sparks, but are drifting towards solitary working instead. If anything, perhaps pubs might be slightly better at it in modern day Britain? My experience living in Cambridge has been that, I think I've had far more scientific discussions in pubs and college bars than I have in cafes.
pubs yes - but caffeine vs alcohol is important<p>the author of the paper avoids giving any weight to two big features:<p>a) all male spaces (not true of modern cafes)
b) almost exclusively white/european<p>it is pointed out that the coffeehouse is a non-European invention - and some of the original proprietors were non-European - he even examines why coffeehouses in the Arab world didn't produce scientific progress - his answer is that they were suppressed by the powers that be<p>the British pub is the closest thing we have today - but they increasingly skew old in age - and are too much IMO "places to drink alcohol" "places to watch football" vs what the coffeehouses represented - they are also relatively expensive
Teahouse in my university university city is closest I have around me. Many are ... central to various scenes. But that is also due to events-hosting. I.e. when I wanted to learn about cohousing, local anarchists had their caffe. There is a tearoom local larpers and kinksters tended to frequent. Stuff like that.
In my area, also a college town, most neighborhood cafes I go to still spark conversation and act as a place where people can meet. Yes some people work there. Or read books.<p>But I actually think cafe culture is pretty healthy in walkable places.<p>One problem is zoning has made it so “neighborhood cafe” is hard to build in the US. Commercial in residential isn’t often allowed.
Plenty of cafés around Paris, which is very walkable. What I see, even outside usual tourist hotspots (I live in a regular residential area with no tourist attraction around), is mostly groups of friends or people working that don't mingle.<p>The zoning situation in the US keeps coming back when subjects like these are discussed on hn. Now, I've never lived there, so I can't talk from experience. But even though I can see why that situation would definitely not help, I think that solving that is far from sufficient. Something else seems to be happening in Western urban societies.
I met a lot of people in my local cafe when I used to study. A few things I think that works:<p>Be there all the time. Cafe is like your second living room. Eventually you will notice the other regulars, and they will notice you. It also means that the coffee and food need to be reasonably priced.<p>Cafe cannot be too busy. It needs to be a chill atmosphere. Chat with hosts first. This often impossible if the cafe is too busy.
Unfortunately it's not just coffee shops, but any and all public spaces. Spontaneous conversation with strangers has largely been killed by the smartphone.
I think the smartphone killed it from two directions: it isn’t safe to make mistakes if everyone is filming, and there is no one bored enough to try making that mistake. With those working together, you can’t have one standout person push past and make it work anyways because it’s coming from both sides. We’ve made a fun catch-22 for ourselves.
> it isn’t safe to make mistakes if everyone is filming<p>there was also an example of this argument in a viral video where a young generation representative was grilling the older folks on some talk show. He was going: "nobody dances anymore, because everyone might be filming"<p>I don't feel like this myself, so I find it hard to associate with. Could you share a couple examples of situations where one might think "I'd do this, but what if someone posts this online later"?
What kind of mistake you imagine people doing in the small talk situation that is visible on random camera capture?
Through to ancient times, it has been written in many stories of boys being afraid to talk to girls. They are scared of the consequences of making a mistake. In the modern day, that same ridicule isn’t limited to a tribe but to the entire world.<p>I think the question you’re asking is whether that fear was ever valid or even true? That one’s outside my pay scale, sorry.
my take is sitting arrangement has a lot to do with it - modern cafes have small seats, usually two or at most four people per table.<p>secondly the coffee is made to be fancy i.e a lot of snobbery involved think blue coffee.<p>for coffee houses to become places of discussion it should be like how shebeens are long benches no solitary seats, drinks served cheaply in one form - black coffee.
My take is that TV killed most social pass times<p>People were so bored all the time they went out to socialise just to have something to do<p>Look at membership rates of clubs and associations over time, they've absolutely plummetted<p>Because the BATNA to socialising/clubs/coffee houses went from sitting at home doing nothing to watching TV
Is this specific to a time period(like the 60s and on or more present day?). I think part of the club membership is that there are also way more clubs today. My local tennis clubs, which also has padel and pickleball, and a full bar…is packed pretty much every evening. (Just anecdata)<p>It’s also getting pretty expensive to do things like hobbies, in the US atleast.
In a college town I used to live in the most popular communal gathering place was a large unglamorous lunch tray style grocery store cafeteria. Booths, big round and rectangle tables, buffet, or super cheap pancakes, eggs, toast, lots of black coffee and fountain drinks. Families, students, retirees catching up. They replaced that with a small restaurant tips and servers and a bar which killed it. That unwillingness to have inefficient use of space per sq foot took the culture with it. Felt like the last days of something before someone crunched the numbers.
I would add that the host matters a lot too. If the host talks to everyone, then you would eventually know others through the host.
clubs originally did not display the deejay, he was on a stage or in a booth. resultantly, the dance floor was a mingled chaotic mix in all directions. nowadays audiences mostly face the deejay like a facsimile of church; people stare at the back of those in front of them. just wanted to back the idea of arrangement affecting social connection.
>> long benches no solitary seats, drinks served cheaply in one form - black coffee.<p>But that denies the reality of the modern coffee experience. Today, coffee is all about visible class separations. It is about speaking the lingo, ordering a ridiculously complicated drink that shows everyone in the room that you are a coffee prosumer. Then we all watch an underpaid "barista" spin into action to create your bespoke foam-covered cup of hot water. If you are very lucky they will make some mistake, empowering you to take a high road and chuckle with your friends about the service [insert Frasier episode] or a low road and demand a correction. When you buy coffee you are buying access to a public display of your social standing ... exactly the opposite of a traditional coffeehouses of centuries past.
That’s one of my dreams to live in a college city and make serious scientific discussions with the students and professors every day :)<p>I wonder if Canada has similar culture and places, need to go to the coffeehouses and pubs near universities to find out.
European salon culture still somewhat exists for example you go to a lecture by a visiting professor and a group after goes out to talk about said lecture.<p>Where these really exist is the classical studies college because all those students are orators. The more I hung out there the more I realized I was in the wrong degree as my major had nothing of the sort of events and salon-like social clubs like they did.
Is it common to do two degrees, one in classics and one in STEM. I always feel that I am dragged towards classics, too, albeit for various reasons —- I’d love to understand Aristotle’s model of Universe and his calculations —- I kinda prefer a Physics/Astronomy education from a historical viewpoint, not directly jumping into Calculus.
Canadian coffee house culture is very similar to the rest of the western world. There is a mix of groups and solo workers but those groups came in as friends. Breaking into one would be tough but not impossible. Pubs are similar but the more commercial ones will start trying to kick you out after an hour or so.<p>If you’re heading to University, your best bet for that is probably to live in a residence on campus and surround yourself with people in the same boat.
Thanks. I plan a reentry into a university in my fifties, so hopefully the vibe is still there. I heard some departments also have their own “meeting room coffee talks” as well, sometimes involving people from other universities, too.
We did 20 years ago. I couldn't say if it's the same now.
When I go to Starbucks, most people are sitting in silence looking at their phones... Even when they come in groups.<p>Because of that, I now have phone-free, 1:1 meetings with friends there.
> Shame that cafes nowadays don't really (seem to) result in this form of conversation<p>Why would I spend time and money going to a cafe in order to converse with strangers when I can do that instantly and online?<p>While previously only those privileged enough to be able to afford the time and resources required to take a break from work in order to gossip, today near anyone can find the time and location to do so.
In Taipei we've been organizing monthly "Fireside Chats" where we spend a couple hours in a cafe or bar, listening to someone in the group present on some topic for a couple minutes, and then discussing it for up to an hour before someone else presents.<p>It's basically a focused hangout trying to capture the vibe of these old salons. People REALLY enjoy it.<p>When I was in Cambridge I thought it'd be the perfect environment for something like that. I met plenty of people there who had no interest in pub culture or drinking and you have several lovely cafes that would work great (weather permitting, personally I'd try to host at The Orchard Tea Garden) for such an event. If you put it on Luma, people will come!
This resonates in the more general case of the university, too. There's little reason anymore to go to office hours, form a study group, ask a classmate for help, etc.<p>Not even trying to make a point on whether it's better or worse for learning per se, but the old people-based way just seems like a much more fun and vibrant academic culture.
I know that online is not the same as in person, but you could get some of the desired effect with a sort of public video meeting website. You might need to structure it cleverly though.<p>Any sites in that vein that I have seen (not sure if I was on any of these though) like Tinychat tended towards very banal and/or group-politic discussions.<p>Discord also has video and audio meetings, but you are already presorted into that specific community. And the interactions are about social positioning in the group as much as they are hyper focused on the subject matter.<p>Maybe Hacker News is the modern coffee house. It's too bad my phone can't actually make me coffee or a pastry.<p>Can't help but think of a virtual online coffeehouse idea.
One core problem that I haven't seen solved with online video/audio for this kind of thing is being able to meander to another group of people, like you do in person at a party or any social event.<p>If there are eight people in person, there may be two or three separate conversations going on. In a video call, there can really only be one since it's all one shared audio space. Now only one conversation can happen at a time.<p>About four or five years ago, I was at a company that used a service called Tandem (I think they're out of business now), which was audio calls with a feature to emulate physical distance with audio getting quieter when you're "further away" from someone. It was interesting, but it still just didn't feel the same. Felt a bit distracting to hear someone who was "at a distance", where the brain feels better at handling that IRL.
>Maybe Hacker News is the modern coffee house<p>That’s what I think. I’ve been in a lot of coffee shops recently and you want something more like HN, even if everyone complains about it. It’s still a pretty good place to hang out, even without a coffee in your hand. Tea is allowed too. But beware liquor and posting.
Definitely, yes. HN is one corner for "intellectual exchange". Although the internet is huge, there are not too many other corners out there, unfortunately. But I think it is equally difficult to find the right coffee house & table & discussion partner in any surrounding. From the article:<p>> findings show that social institutions can raise the production and use of knowledge by broadening access to intellectual exchange beyond formal academic networks
So modern day equivalents might be Maker spaces?<p>There’s also online communities: forums, game boards, HNews itself of course.<p>But I’m guessing in person is a bigger deal.<p>There used to be Skillsmatter CodeNode in London, which was such a key focus for years. (Big thanks to Wendy)<p>But neutral venues for Meet-ups seems to be hard work
Not only in-person, but the smaller population size - and presumably the smaller social circle of those involved I should read the paper!) would mean the patrons of these coffeehouses were less likely to be strangers.<p>I could go to a coffee shop or bar right now, but I'm unlikely to start a conversation with a stranger about science or philosophy. Might be on me :)
Yes, I’m guessing this is third-space territory, recurrent social fixtures.<p>There’s a whole social ecology to a city, for want of better words.<p>A city with these structures for people to meet and get to know each other; would one would think be able to have more ferment in new companies and social cohesion.<p>Sweden has a start-up culture, I’m wondering does it have avenues for people to meetup too. Is it only in certain Swedish cities.<p>I guess there’s an Francisco too, is a university the key catalyst?
I think the problem with online spaces is they're both very easy to get into, and very hard - so it's easy to stick your head into a massive Discord group, but you're also quite unlikely to just stumble into a conversation that's particularly relevant to your interests.
Discord
I wonder: the very same model of the coffeehouse had existed in the Ottoman Empire (where it originated) since the 16th century, yet it did not spark a scientific revolution.<p>Maybe English scientists were already prepared for such a change in science and coffeehouses just made it possible as a simple catalyst?
I'm not a historian, but I think the scientific revolution partly came from protestantism -> the desire to <i>read</i> the bible (rather than hear it interpreted by a priest) -> the printing press.
The bottom of page 32 in the paper (with more details in footnote 56) seems to address this: in the Ottoman empire, coffee houses were an institution of the ruler, which led to them being a rightly controlled environment, sometimes even closed in fear of them being used to plot sedition. To give rise to science, the scene in coffee houses needed to be independent, which wasn't present in the Ottoman empire. That seems plausible.
And such watering holes were indeed hotbeds of sedition, especially in Europe, because people had to plot in secret since there was no democratic means of regime change. Other notable meeting places included places of worship, Masonic lodges, and even hamams!
If I had a few hundred thousand dollars laying around, I’d open a cafe that is explicitly focused on conversations: no electronics allowed, long tables with many chairs, big comfy chairs arranged in a circle, nightly themed discussions, etc.<p>I don’t know if it would work, and you might scare off the traditional coffee shop laptop class, but man it would be an awesome place to spend some time.
This business model works as there’s a place like this I frequent. It focuses on having tables so you can play board games and they sell used books.<p>One of the things I like about it is that is not just coffee focused. They have a bar, snacks, some light entrees that are uncomplicated for a small kitchen, and desserts. Basically, there’s something for everyone’s taste, especially since if you really think about it, this type of business is way more biased towards evening hours.<p>Nobody’s going to go to a no-WiFi coffee shop during the workday since people are at work.<p>A traditional coffee shop is seen by many as somewhat utilitarian as far as getting coffee, breakfast, or a small break from work. That’s why they’ve coalesced around feeling more like a McDonald’s than a third place.
Where are you in the world? A couple hundred thousand would work in Taiwan or Thailand but not many other places... Try closer to a million imo. And don't expect it to make money anytime soon!<p>I've dreamt of building a place like this but more as a community space, perhaps even a co-op. Some group of people cover rent, and anyone can host events for whatever reason including just to pull revenue. Perhaps we pool to cover staff and have it be a normal cafe in the day, or just work it ourselves.<p>I think I'm always just trying to replicate Food Camp at our local Burn... People just lounging and chatting while I sling pancakes. I replicated it when I started a restaurant here and survived all of 8 months before the damn thing nearly killed me, but 8 months with a counter top open kitchen setup where I could chat with every customer that dined in... It was a dream. We had some really fun conversations with a hugely eclectic group of people, often bilingually so we'd really get some diverse perspectives. For example, we were near both the Framework office and the Taiwanese FBI, so we'd alternatively get in firmware engineers and feds.
Great paper! The connection between coffeehouses and the progress of science is fascinating. Similarly, it would be interesting to see how watchmakers contributed to the development of precision instruments,metrology and, in turn, the progress of science and modern technology.
I would also love to see how glassblowers contributed to the development of laboratory equipment, enabling new scientific discoveries.<p>For example, Ebenezer Everett, a glassblower who worked with J.J.Thomson at the Cavendish Laboratory.<p><a href="https://www.gracesguide.co.uk/Ebenezer_Everett" rel="nofollow">https://www.gracesguide.co.uk/Ebenezer_Everett</a><p><a href="https://blog.sciencemuseum.org.uk/jj-thomsons-cathode-ray-tube/" rel="nofollow">https://blog.sciencemuseum.org.uk/jj-thomsons-cathode-ray-tu...</a>
>watchmakers contributed to the development of precision instruments,metrology and, in turn, the progress of science and modern technology.<p>The Mettler "portion" of Mettler-Toledo was directly descended from precision swiss watchmakers who turned their attention to scientific instruments.<p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mettler_Toledo" rel="nofollow">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mettler_Toledo</a>
I wonder how much of any of this has anything to do with nicotine. I was just thinking yesterday, I never had as many active social contacts as way back when I was a smoker.
About the first part i like the idea of how the people from all classes they was sharing ideas that's great thing but now adays the class divisions are increasing, between poor and rich between who knows and who don't know between the cultures and a lot of things, and because of that the people becomes addicted to things that are un healthy like the bad side of social media (shorts ...), and because of all of those that let the people becomes far from each other instead of becoming more closer and that killed the creativity. Because of that you see all the things that are discovered and created are from the people who are boring(in other words genius people).
Nowadays most of the interactions exist online, and because life is busier, coffeehouse is no longer a symbol of free interaction because few people, rich or poor, have any free time. There are many business discussions in coffeehouses, though.<p>I do agree such a place is perfect for scientific discussion, but the owner needs to allow and encourage it.
The scientific revolution was successful. Contributing meaningful to the frontiers now means many years of dedicated study first. Scientists already know everyone in their sub-field that they could learn from.
That's great point about free time, but even if the people goes to coffeehouse they will be busy holding their phones or laptops and sitting alone without any interaction.
Coffeehouses feature prominently in the Baroque Cycle by Neal Stephenson, where one of the protagonists, Daniel Waterhouse, mingles with people such as Leibniz, Hooke, Wren, Newton, etc.
I wonder about the current coffee places in the City of London (other financial centres are available) and the effect on financial decisions.<p>Speaking of, 'Wild & Wood' on London Wall is very nice - great cakes, nice coffee. Wooden benches that look like they are from churches maybe.
So all those people with MacBooks turning coffee shops into coworking spaces are actually advancing scientific progress. And baristas keep trying to stop them by enforcing laptop-free hours :)
Reminds me of a situation I found myself in about 10 years ago. I was sitting outside a t a small coffee house somewhere in Palo Alto. It was early in the morning and I was preparing for a few potential investor meetings later that day.<p>A person walked around the corner, and I recognised him instantly. It was a well known investor. I am not a very social person and I tend to act as if I haven't noticed anything when I see people I might know. But this man is a bit of a hero for me. I'd read his blog for so many years and really enjoyed his insights.<p>Against my normal behaviour I got up, walked to him, and said, Sir, you do not know me, but I know you and I have a lot of respect for the things you have done for the tech community. I just wanted to say that, sorry for the intrusion.<p>He was surprised, but he shook hands, and without me intending anything he sat down and we had a super fun conversation about the world we live in. He ended up asking me why I was here and gave me some tips, which was very nice of him.<p>Not sure if it added anything to society or technical sciences, but that still is one of my favorite moments in Silicon Valley.
Is this a case of correlation being mistaken for causation? Could coffee shops just open up in trendy areas that also attract scientists, without actually causing science to happen? How would one test for this?
I can’t get into liking coffee? I love the smell of it, and in food but I just can’t get into drinking it. James Hoffman is wasted on me.
I wonder how much regulation makes these spaces emerging harder. Eg, I imagine 300 years ago, starting a coffee house for you and your mates to chat shop was relatively "easy"?
This proved out anecdotally in my life. The period before laptop computers came into the world where my opinion, one of the most vibrant times to be alive during the late 90s. The amount of discussions I had with strangers whether it’s spiritual or scientific just blows me away.<p>But with the advent of laptops, everyone became solitary and unwilling to be interrupted. I still try to talk to people, but unlike when people are reading a book people on laptop seem not to want to be disturbed.
What are the strengths and weaknesses of science?
[flagged]
[flagged]
[dead]