I posted on one a few months ago and got so much AI spam it was useless. AI isn’t causing the cuts so much as making it insanely difficult to filter
It is peculiar - everyone busy, companies still firing. AI is doing more but to me it feels like companies are using AI to scale more than they are to cut heads (I honestly don't have a big enough sample to form any real basis for this other than its what I've witnessed talking to various people).<p>Also, despite the big tech layoffs, somehow unemployment numbers not reflecting higher unemployment <a href="https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/unemployment-rate" rel="nofollow">https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/unemployment-rate</a>
I think article is showing a trend for HN job postings but also think we cannot make too many assumptions with a decline of 387 postings -> 244<p>HN job postings don't equal the software job market. That said I feel bleak about the whole thing :(
Broad unemployment is not significantly higher.<p>HN gets a lot more traffic than 12 years ago too now, so this trend is probably even more significant.
Is that AI or is it just the economic depression?
Outside tech hiring, we’re not even in a recession. Q3 GDP growth was 3.4% on an annualized basis. U6 unemployment is below 8%, which has happened just a few times since 2000: <a href="https://www.macrotrends.net/1377/u6-unemployment-rate" rel="nofollow">https://www.macrotrends.net/1377/u6-unemployment-rate</a>.<p>Also, aside from the period when the government was handing out checks during covid, median monthly real wages (adjusted for inflation) are near record highs: <a href="https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/les1252881600Q" rel="nofollow">https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/les1252881600Q</a>
What economic depression. Stock market is close to alltime highs
These threads are overwhelmed by US postings. Is there evidence of an economic depression in the USA? Because I can't find anything indicating this.
No. Its true that covid did take a hard smack at the economy and wage growth didn't keep up with rising cost of living for a while after, but that is going back to normal. High interest rates do make it more difficult to own a home and there's a feeling of stagnation, but its not a decline as far as I can see in the numbers. Americans, the richest people in human history, just are very unsatisfied with their lot in life and want so much more. If we don't own a sports car and have a 2nd home on lake tahoe we feel like complete losers.
The stability that comes from amassing wealth is just table stakes. There are definitely poor Americans, but what all Americans actually want is <i>novelty</i>. They're bored.
Try caring about ordinary people just getting started in adulthood. My parents bought a house as cashiers. Walmart and Target employees need welfare and can never buy a house. They had similarly-aged families around and parents to help. My street is now mostly retirees who don't even have to pay property taxes, while us few working families are shouldering the burden and it's too expensive for my parents to live nearby and help. And we're the lucky ones! This country sucks. Maybe the blue tsunami will help, but orange is still occupying the president's seat.
A little bit of this, a little bit of that.
Do you mean that blip in 2023 when the stock market took a shit? Remote work cooled down somewhat and so did senior hiring. That's clearly shown in the graphs.
does the remote part also counts post that mention REMOTE US<p>because most of the remote postings do
After 18 months without a job (I got DOGE'd), I gave the hell up and joined the resraurant biz. My back hurts every night, but I get free food and AI can't take it away. Turns out 20+ years of watching Gordon Ramsay shows helped a lot too - picked up some good (probably) work habits.<p>Shame, nobody else would even TALK to me about working for them.
So, "who is hiring" posts on <i>this specific website</i> went up from ~2015 until ~2022, and have fallen back to their pre-2015 average.<p>Suggesting this is due to AI is...extremely motivated reasoning. Among other obvious confounders, this overlaps strongly with changes in interest rates (at least on the rising end; 2022), and section 174 changes that took effect in 2022.
Yup, been saying this for roughly a year now. AI will reduce the need for software developers. This post will get downvoted. Reality sucks, nobody wants to hear it, and truth stings.<p>Those that keep their jobs will very likely see a reduction in pay in the next ~5 years.<p>Good luck all.
I agree with you that we will probably see a reduction in pay, but not because of a reduction in software engineers or need for software.<p>We are going through a period of “deskilling” that many other industries have also seen in the past. This has historically resulted in pay reduction.
Nobody wants to hear it because its not as black and white. There are still more software developers actually employed than a decade ago and the market really just isn't that bad if you really look at the numbers carefully (with the exception being recent graduates). But the news is pushing the narrative that there is a total carnage ongoing for software developers with no future ahead, which really doesn't seem to be true (if you go by pure numbers and compare against 10-20 year trends).
The market for us new grads seems quite bad right now, add to that my misfortune that I am quite interested in Systems which have even lower amount of jobs. I have done some impressive work (if I may say so myself, <a href="https://himwant.org/posts/redox-eevdf/" rel="nofollow">https://himwant.org/posts/redox-eevdf/</a> ), but damn is it hard to find a single job opening right now.
With hyperinflation why would there be a reduction in pay? The high performers will stick around and pay reductions are rare compared to layoffs.
Might be a combination of both AI and markets pricing in recession odds.
[dead]