It's because carbon reduction has not been disconnected from material impoverishment. We need more stuff moving; we need more housing, we need more transport, we need more food, we need more energy, we need more children. Carbon reduction's story is one of denying/reducing these things in the name of saving planet earth. The answer needs to be doing both: reducing carbon <i>and</i> making more houses and food and energy and babies. Nobody really wants to be DINK pod-people who have little optionality in life activities, and that's what climate change warriors are selling them.
My personal experience has been the opposite, and for the most part energy efficiency, renewables, and so on, usually, but not always, perform better than fossil fuels.<p>The reason why comes down to exergy. In most cases, we can extract more useful work from a kwh of electricity than a kwh of fossil fuels. And people can usually get more food, more useful energy, more transport, and if they want more kids, in a renewables based economy.
The idea of "unbounded capitalism", leading to incessant growth, while painting reductions as "impoverishment", is a capital error.<p>Reality doesn't allow for any such thing and wishing for it doesn't make it so.<p>Consequently, ignoring that reality will see you running into a wall head-on. With wildly devastating consequences: El Niño is just one immediate symptom, look at the AMOC. It collapsing will see about 70% or more of Earth's population wiped out. Along with the corresponding capacity for crop growth.<p>What you need to do is <i>actually preventing</i> foreseeable calamities, not complaining about people pointing you at them.
rustcleaner didn't say that his or her suggested solution is capitalism, though it might be.<p>People in communism, or nearly any other socioeconomic system, also want more housing, transport, food, energy, and children.<p>Reality includes public opinion, which even authoritarian systems have to account for to some extent. So even if the reality is that climate change will be so devastating that it needs to be addressed by any means necessary (I don't know if that is the reality, but let's say for the sake of argument that it is), that necessity has to be sold to people somehow.<p>And it's difficult to convince people to accept impoverishment if the truly major negative consequences of not acting on climate change are ones that will not happen for decades, as seems to be the case at least in temperate regions. I know very little about AMOC, but it seems the science about AMOC collapse timelines is not settled enough to convince the average person that something must be done immediately.<p>To get public buy-in in such a situation, it may be more advantageous to figure out how to be able to sell the necessary changes in a way that is not accompanied by impoverishment. That or ignore public buy-in, but then one still has to figure out how to do that. Voters punish economic decline. And I doubt that there is a realistic path to replacing Western democracy with an authoritarian system that has climate change as a top priority, at least in the near future.
People "wanting" whatever doesn't mean, they could get it.<p>Note how absurd the framing here is: "impoverishment" of whom and meaning what? US Americans, among the richest in the world, "falling" to the <i>average</i>? Who is supposed to pity them exactly?<p>Your idea of "consequences not happening for decades": WTF? So, so long as its not you who bears the downsides, you don't care? How sympathetic.<p>"Public buy in" is a chimera. You propose, they would buy into anything they're being told, so long as it sounds attractive to them. What's that supposed to mean?<p>Either, the public believes anything they're being told anyway, or they have to actually grow up and learn to <i>know</i> the truth themselves. It's not about whatever nonsense "political system", it's about <i>epistemology</i>.<p>As for the AMOC timeline: you could use your own rational mind to figure that out, but you prefer for others to tell you. Unless they tell you what you don't want to hear? Seriously?
"A society grows great when old men plant trees whose shade they know they shall never sit in"<p>-Greek proverb you've probably heard before
Imagine that ... people warring against an existential threat to human civilization.
| Carbon reduction's story is one of denying/reducing these things in the name of saving planet earth<p>saving our species<p>The earth will do fine, and probably better, once we extinct ourselves
What a load of baloney. Keep it in the ground. Build interconnect, solar, wind and batteries. Regulate for generation efficiency, better mpg, build out charging infra and public transpo. Eliminate subsidies for beef, O&G.<p>It’s a lie that decarbonization is going to result in material impoverishment. “Oh my things!!”
You're right, we're SINKs instead. Nobody wants to cohabitate with each other or agree with each other and think it's cute and funny to poke fun at each other.
>that's what climate change warriors are selling them.<p>Interesting way to frame the constraints of reality.
Maybe I misunderstood, but I think they’re saying that the constraints of reality include, “If their answer requires lesser production, movement, and quality of life, then it never was a thoughtful answer.”<p>It’s not far from what I’ve always thought. We simply will not solve these problems with broad self-denial. It’s an absurd notion, even if the monastic sheen of it sounds nice.