8 comments

  • jopsen26 minutes ago
    &gt; Sguros filed a complaint against the real estate company in February, saying in filings that he discovered West in the home while he was on duty and detailing how he subsequently began to clean, secure and invest in the property. However, he never established in his records that he came to be involved in the home through a purchase, lease, probate appointment, deed or relationship with West’s heirs, the arrest affidavit said.<p>Wow, cops certainly know how to produce a confession.
  • kaydub2 hours ago
    Cop stole house from dead man. Then cop sued company that rightfully bought house from dead man&#x27;s heirs?
    • JumpCrisscross2 hours ago
      It’s always surprising how craftiness and intelligence, which one would expect to be joined at the hip, can exist almost independently to each other.
      • nostrademons22 minutes ago
        It looks like he was working toward an adverse possession claim. In Florida it&#x27;s 7 years of &quot;open and notorious&quot; possession, as well as paying all property taxes (which it sounds like he did), filing a letter with the appraiser&#x27;s office (which it sounds like he did), and improving the property (which he did). His adverse possession claim was interrupted 4 years into the 7 year clock, and then he tried to file an &quot;unjust enrichment&quot; claim to get the money he spent on the property back.<p>His big mistake was forging the signature and impersonating the decedent. If he&#x27;d just signed under his own name and hoped nobody noticed, no felonies would&#x27;ve been committed and he would have a case to get back the $200K in the &quot;unjust enrichment&quot; lawsuit.
      • RunSet15 minutes ago
        <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.merriam-webster.com&#x2F;dictionary&#x2F;low%20cunning" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.merriam-webster.com&#x2F;dictionary&#x2F;low%20cunning</a>
        • JumpCrisscross12 minutes ago
          This is different. I&#x27;m not commenting on morality. I&#x27;m saying they were cunning enough to pull this off–and get away with it for many years–but not smart enough to realize that pressing this legal claim would cause him to lose everything.
      • p1necone59 minutes ago
        I&#x27;ve long thought that pure desire&#x2F;drive is <i>much</i> more important than intelligence in just about everything, including things that stereotypically require intelligence like programming, math etc.
        • Fricken40 minutes ago
          By &quot;everything&quot; I&#x27;m presuming you mean the trivial little games that humans these days are preoccupied with. You can play those games if you like, but they won&#x27;t save you. Everybody dies in the end no matter how smart or motivated they are. The final score is always zero.
          • JumpCrisscross2 minutes ago
            &gt; <i>Everybody dies in the end no matter how smart or motivated they are. The final score is always zero</i><p>This system of morality is cute when we compare a rich man and a pauper. It falls on its face when we compare a violent heathen and someone who tried to live well. It&#x27;s lazy nihilism by another name, an absolution of moral agency, albeit with compelling dressing.
          • recursive30 minutes ago
            For your way of scoring maybe. If I can see and do some cool stuff along the way and maybe even love, then my final score will be non-zero, according to my scoring system.
      • lazide2 hours ago
        In this case, more like sometime someone can buy their lies so much even they start to believe them?
      • tanseydavid2 hours ago
        I cannot help but wonder, &quot;What did the cop do with the body?&quot;
        • triceratops1 hour ago
          The story has a video showing paramedics or someone taking the body away on a stretcher.
        • wrs1 hour ago
          I take it you stopped reading before the fifth paragraph.
        • josefritzishere1 hour ago
          [dead]
  • apt-apt-apt-apt41 minutes ago
    That&#x27;s one way to get a home.<p>This sounds bonkers, but there was a kernel of legal strategy here - adverse possession, basically a statute of limitations on getting your land back.
  • triceratops1 hour ago
    &gt; Sguros [the cop] claimed he spent at least $214,000 of his own money on the home.<p>If he spent so much, why not just buy his own house? The house in the article is nothing special to look at.
    • fallinghawks1 hour ago
      A real estate website tells me the average in that city is $400K. But it does seem pretty dumb to spend that amount of money on improvements when you know damn well your ownership is fraudulent and may come back to bite you.
      • JumpCrisscross1 minute ago
        It looks like he might have been going for turbo squatter&#x27;s rights [1].<p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=50215874">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=50215874</a>
    • cowlevel1 hour ago
      does a house cost below $214,000 now? I haven&#x27;t heard the news that the market crashed.
      • Jtsummers1 hour ago
        $214k is more than I have spent on the home I &quot;own&quot; (have a mortgage on) even adding in my downpayment over the last 7 years. He could have bought a home for what he claims to have spent.
        • cowlevel59 minutes ago
          A house price is a house price, you can&#x27;t say it&#x27;s only 20%.
          • Jtsummers56 minutes ago
            Your original comment to which I was replying when you edited your comment:<p>&gt; You have to count the total amount you will pay on the mortgage.<p>Yes. That&#x27;s what I was counting, I have <i>spent</i> less than $214k on my house, repairs and mortgage.<p>Your comment after that was edited:<p>&gt; A house price is a house price, you can&#x27;t say it&#x27;s only 20%.<p>What are you talking about? The question is could he have afforded a house for $214k, and the answer is <i>yes</i>. Houses in that area don&#x27;t cost a minimum of $1 million, even the house he attempted to steal wasn&#x27;t worth that much.
            • cowlevel52 minutes ago
              A house price of $214k is not the same as a down payment of $214k
            • jrflowers51 minutes ago
              cowlevel is saying that they know what a down payment is but also thinks that you can’t buy a house that costs more than the amount of money you have in the bank
              • Jtsummers45 minutes ago
                If that&#x27;s what they believe they&#x27;re a strange person. Very few people buy houses in the US with cash in the bank equal to the home price. They buy them with mortgages. And someone who can spend $214k on home repair work over 4 years could have afforded a pretty decent house with that same cash and a mortgage.
      • triceratops43 minutes ago
        When a fraudulently obtained house costs $214k you may as well spend the $400k average house price in that city and avoid jail forever. Staying out of jail and continuing to work as a cop is easily worth more than $200k.
  • SoftTalker1 hour ago
    Assuming the identity of a dead person was (is still?) a common form of fraud. People (usually relatives) could collect pension and social security payments sometimes for years before being discovered (if they ever were).
    • chrisco25525 minutes ago
      It&#x27;s crazy that we have such a disjointed system that someone can die and the Federal government is unable to timely discover and process death records.
  • jrflowers58 minutes ago
    That he is being prosecuted for this is a sad example of why officers need stronger qualified immunity for snap decisions made in the line of duty
    • _eyewumbo19 minutes ago
      To be fair, he likely wasn&#x27;t trained not to impersonate a dead man and steal his house
      • jrflowers2 minutes ago
        Our law enforcement heroes are trained to tactically “take shelter” but when one does so strategically it is branded a “crime”
    • ethin48 minutes ago
      I can&#x27;t tell if this is satire or not, but I&#x27;m suspecting that it is
      • jrflowers42 minutes ago
        Who is to say he wasn’t in fear for his life when he stole the house? Maybe the house committed a crime and he was detaining it. Civilians just don’t know the challenges faced by our boys in blue
    • phs318u51 minutes ago
      You forgot the &#x2F;s
  • paxy53 minutes ago
    The most surprising part of this story is that a police officer got arrested and charged with a felony.
    • breezybottom51 minutes ago
      Happens like every week. Maybe you just don&#x27;t read news outside HN.
      • iAMkenough6 minutes ago
        Which news outlet would you recommend? Weekly updates about cops getting charged with felonies would be interesting.