21 comments

  • wkjagt16 minutes ago
    I know this is probably a very naive question, but what is the end goal putting so much effort into getting past ad blockers? Surely, someone with an ad blocker installed is not going to click on their ads and buy the advertised products anyway. I don&#x27;t really know what I am talking about, but I guess it&#x27;s all about ad impressions that generate money, but doesn&#x27;t this strategy end up making less money, because the money that&#x27;s put into circumventing ad blockers isn&#x27;t really generating more sales.<p>It&#x27;s like a door to door sales person thinking that if only they could find a way to unlock my door I would buy their stuff.
    • Lammy5 minutes ago
      Ads are for surveillance as much if not more than they are for money
    • SvenL12 minutes ago
      Aren’t ads payed also via „impressions“, like 10k people saw your advertisement so please pay x money?
      • seattle_spring0 minutes ago
        Partially, yes. Ads are also psychological, and tracked cross-platform. If you see a BMW ad on Facebook, drive by a BMW billboard on the highway, search BMW on Google, and then go buy a BMW, they have ways of fractionally allocating the conversion to the different impressions. It&#x27;s pretty crazy.
  • hn_submit21 minutes ago
    The only way to keep ads off Facebook is to stop using Facebook.
    • CivBase0 minutes ago
      If you&#x27;re still using Facebook, it&#x27;s because you&#x27;re required to or you&#x27;re the kind of person who won&#x27;t be fazed by this.
  • nemomarx1 hour ago
    <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=49271126">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=49271126</a><p>More discussion here
    • WalterGR1 hour ago
      With 104 comments at the moment, that’s where the bulk of the discussion is happening.
  • qbane1 hour ago
    I wrote and shared uBlock Origin filters for Facebook, shared on Reddit and up to a week later they changed the DOM structure bypassed the filters. After some attempts I no longer publish the filters.
    • amelius1 hour ago
      Maybe a better approach is to convert the page to an image, run OCR over it, use an LLM to remove the ads, present the result to the user.
      • ImJamal54 minutes ago
        How would you comment or watch a video if you did that?
        • amelius46 minutes ago
          You can still do that.<p>The only thing I&#x27;m proposing is to do the filtering on graphical data (what the user actually sees) rather than on the DOM (which can be obfuscated; and which may change every week).
  • fsuts6 minutes ago
    Facebook and instagram constantly email me trying to entice me to use the app. As I haven’t used it for years.<p>I think it’s purely to massage their Active Monthly User numbers to show growth.
    • zuhsetaqi1 minute ago
      &gt; I think it’s purely to massage their Active Monthly User numbers to show growth.<p>I don&#x27;t think so. They want you to use the App because through the they have way more ways to track you.
  • Cider99861 hour ago
    Here&#x27;s the source:<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;reddit.com&#x2F;r&#x2F;uBlockOrigin&#x2F;comments&#x2F;1vgcjg5" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;reddit.com&#x2F;r&#x2F;uBlockOrigin&#x2F;comments&#x2F;1vgcjg5</a><p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;old.reddit.com&#x2F;r&#x2F;uBlockOrigin&#x2F;comments&#x2F;1vgcjg5&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;old.reddit.com&#x2F;r&#x2F;uBlockOrigin&#x2F;comments&#x2F;1vgcjg5&#x2F;</a><p>Archived comments &#x2F; VPN: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;photon-reddit.com&#x2F;r&#x2F;uBlockOrigin&#x2F;comments&#x2F;1vgcjg5&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;photon-reddit.com&#x2F;r&#x2F;uBlockOrigin&#x2F;comments&#x2F;1vgcjg5&#x2F;</a>
  • curt154 minutes ago
    &quot;What do you do for work?&quot;<p>&quot;I find ways to defeat adblockers&quot;
  • mattrighetti24 minutes ago
    I&#x27;m more surprised by the fact that people still use Facebook
    • HackerThemAll0 minutes ago
      Those childish comments are so funny. 3 billion people use Facebook regularly, and there are folks that deem themselves superior to all others who claim &quot;I know nobody who uses Facebook&quot;. XD
    • skeeter202018 minutes ago
      remember the amazing show &quot;community&quot;?<p>Elroy: “I got a job through LinkedIn.”<p>Annie: “What? That’s crazy! People use LinkedIn?”<p>Elroy: “No, LinkedIn hired me to help figure out why people don’t use it.”
      • Capricorn24810 minutes ago
        That&#x27;s an underrated season, imo. Keith David is fantastic.
  • la_fayette1 hour ago
    ok thanking the team for this work over the years. i hope yt will stay ad-free :-)
  • conradfr1 hour ago
    Not sure detailing how Facebook demoralized them is the best idea.
    • mattrighetti18 minutes ago
      Well, uBlock is entirely open source so...
  • dzonga1 hour ago
    the tragedy is &#x27;mainstreet&#x27; runs on Facebook.<p>not shitter, google but fb. some local business don&#x27;t even have their own sites but maintain an insta &#x2F; fb page.
    • zamadatix1 hour ago
      Shitter? Edit: Ah, I assume you&#x27;re referring to X (previously Twitter -&gt; shitter taunt)
    • ravetcofx50 minutes ago
      It&#x27;s where the GenX-ers and boomers are at who have money to spend
      • SV_BubbleTime39 minutes ago
        I love how Facebook has one reputation, an Instagram has another and they often don’t match at all even though we all know it’s the exact fucking service with a different skin and theme.
      • makerofthings21 minutes ago
        What&#x27;s with this current trend of grouping GenX with Boomers? I am GenX and the difference between us and Boomers is wild. My GenX friends are on here. Boomers I know are afraid of self-checkout machines.
    • kotaKat31 minutes ago
      the ONLY way my county communicates emergency alerts is facebook. it&#x27;s absolutely wild. how do I know if I&#x27;m in a state of emergency? facebook. :)
      • MrDrMcCoy19 minutes ago
        Your country has sold your safety to private interests. Demand better from them.
  • iugtmkbdfil8341 hour ago
    It is an interesting experiment. Ads on my network are mostly blocked, but wife did notice a spike on her FB stuff. Now that she knows how nice ( edit: well, not automatically awful ) net is without ads, lets see if accepts the trade off.
  • bmurphy19761 hour ago
    All the more reason to block Facebook completely.
  • vachina50 minutes ago
    uBlock hit them where it hurts. Facebook&#x27;s entire existence hinges on serving ads.
  • dabber211 hour ago
    Out of spite they should have a block list, blocking every meta related service, disabled by default... for now
  • tonyhart715 minutes ago
    I know this is gonna be unpopular take<p>but for modern social media to function, they need showing ads to pay creator<p>many people livelihood depends on it, creator make content in turn of revenue sharing that user get for free
  • maxwellito1 hour ago
    Hot take: uBlock origin could insert even MORE ads into Facebook? Discouraging people to use Facebook, and also make some money on the side.<p>(this is a joke obviously, but boy that would be fun and against the T&amp;C)
    • Rebelgecko1 hour ago
      Other adblock tools have gone the route of allowing &quot;good&quot; ads through and only blocking &quot;bad&quot; ads. Of course the definition of good vs bad might depend on who sponsors the dev.
  • zeafoamrun1 hour ago
    I misread the domain as &quot;digital cesspools&quot; and that is indeed what Facebook is. If you&#x27;re still on there you&#x27;re going to get subjected to their abusive practices.
  • OhMeadhbh3 hours ago
    Oh! The Irony! This page doesn&#x27;t load when your ad blocker is turned on.
    • Pooge16 minutes ago
      Are you not using uBlock Origin?
    • OhMeadhbh3 hours ago
      Apropos of nothing, I noted @markoff said they liked John Markoff in the 80s. As a complete aside, may I recommend to readers Markoff&#x27;s book &quot;What the Dormouse Said.&quot; From 2005, it&#x27;s a deep-dive into the relationship between 60s counter-culture and 70s &#x2F; 80s era microcomputer movers and shakers. Want to read about Doug Engelbart tripping balls in the Santa Cruz Mountains? It&#x27;s in there. Or maybe I just made that up in a LSD fueled trip to the center of my mind. But that KIND of thing is in there. Abbie Hoffman somehow influenced Steve Jobs fascination with PARC derived WIMP systems. An image of Richard Nixon getting his face punched was burned into the original PC BIOS ROMs. Tim O&#x27;Leary developed software in the 80s. One of these is not true, but you have to read the book to find out which.<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;search.worldcat.org&#x2F;title&#x2F;57068812" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;search.worldcat.org&#x2F;title&#x2F;57068812</a>
    • delduca1 hour ago
      Not for me (Wipr2 on Safari), loads fine without ADS.
    • squigz1 hour ago
      It works here.
    • usern202607201 hour ago
      try loading it with JS off
  • rosstex1 hour ago
    why not just run a 24&#x2F;7 agent to do the work for them?
    • seritools1 hour ago
      why not &quot;just&quot; do it for them?
  • sleepybrett35 minutes ago
    Another reminder that facebook is abhorrent and not worth your time.