7 comments

  • stronglikedan29 minutes ago
    The thing is that I can get just as good if not better ones (metal) for $7 all day long, and not have to spend time sourcing and assembling materials, and I don't even have to leave my house to do it.
  • colinbartlett1 hour ago
    I was shocked to see that a "brand name" stethoscope is $100+ and even generic ones are $30.
    • jcims21 minutes ago
      I&#x27;m shocked that you&#x27;re shocked lol.<p>$100 for a somewhat specialized, durable medical device that has to meet regulatory standards and will be used daily, possibly for years, by healthcare providers to do patient assessments?<p>A 3D printed option is going to require a 3D printer, appropriate filament and should be unit tested to ensure it&#x27;s within spec. The durability is going to be suspect no matter what. It&#x27;s an awesome project and I&#x27;m sure would be a welcome addition to the &#x27;boostrap humanity&#x27; catalog of 3D printed parts, but for everyday doctors plunking a hundo on a good tool is going to be a no-brainer.
    • elAhmo30 minutes ago
      It is somewhat of a critical tool, so you don&#x27;t wanna be checked by a doctor who made their own stethoscope or got one for 3 USD on AliExpress.
      • NewsaHackO9 minutes ago
        It’s funny, most physicians agree that the cheap disposable stethoscopes in isolation rooms are the best, mostly because they are so loud it’s difficult miss anything with them. However, I am not a cardiologist so they may have a different opinion.
      • recursivegirth23 minutes ago
        Our one that DIY&#x27;d one like one would do a dosing rod in their garage.
    • deknos28 minutes ago
      You probably pay for tests and that the company has to be audited for medical diagnostics standards
    • donaltroddyn36 minutes ago
      They can become a lot more expensive than $100, but the difference between a Littman Cardiology and the $15 EMT student stethoscope is night and day.<p>&gt; Currently, the stethoscope resulting from this project functions as well as the market gold standard, the Littmann Cardiology III<p>If this is true, it&#x27;s a major achievement.
    • unsupp0rted54 minutes ago
      Is that a lot or a little?
      • hungryhobbit39 minutes ago
        This &quot;recipe&quot; produces them for $5 ... that&#x27;s 5% of the market price.
        • mikeyouse31 minutes ago
          Assuming equivalent capabilities and longevity.. I know physicians who have used their &quot;20x too expensive&quot; Littmann for 30 years.
      • Agingcoder39 minutes ago
        À lot
  • abdullahkhalids17 minutes ago
    What&#x27;s the price per use compared to a standard industrial metal one?
  • samantha_greene1 hour ago
    No pictures? Missed opportunity. Seems cool though!
    • bradrn1 hour ago
      The linked paper has some pictures: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;doi.org&#x2F;10.1371&#x2F;journal.pone.0193087" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;doi.org&#x2F;10.1371&#x2F;journal.pone.0193087</a>
      • esc8611 hour ago
        <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;journals.plos.org&#x2F;plosone&#x2F;article&#x2F;figure?id=10.1371&#x2F;journal.pone.0193087.g001" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;journals.plos.org&#x2F;plosone&#x2F;article&#x2F;figure?id=10.1371&#x2F;...</a>
  • jader20138 minutes ago
    Instructional video: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;u-KNTc0POLA" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;u-KNTc0POLA</a>
  • Modified301947 minutes ago
    Do the design and materials take into account how well it can be sterilized?
    • zabzonk44 minutes ago
      Never seen a UK doctor or nurse attempt to clean, much les sterilize, one.
      • jwcacces40 minutes ago
        There are disposable, single-patient stethoscopes, but I&#x27;ve seen my Dr do a casual wipe with an alcohol swab often enough...
      • xyzzy_plugh37 minutes ago
        I think this is a good point, insofar that how bacterial resistant the stethoscope is relevant. Stethoscopes made of stainless steel are going to beat anything 3d printed by a significant margin.
  • brcmthrowaway56 minutes ago
    Are sthethoscopes passive or active devices?
    • kfarr45 minutes ago
      passive