Question 9 imho is the most German one ("When someone says 'we should get coffee sometime,' you understand this to mean:").<p>It depends on context a bit obviously, but most Germans are sincere about it. You either propose coffee or you don't.<p>However, there's a subset of Germans who seem to propose coffee and then don't follow up themselves, but it's not just a phrase. If you are the one to follow up, they'd join you. Which, to say the least, is annoying, too.<p>From my German perspective, asking someone for grabbing coffee sometime and not meaning it is a completely stupid thing to say. Why would you suggest it? Why should the other person have to decode this as a "nice thing to say but not meant literally" if you could say a hundred other things that could be meant literally and are still nice, like "see you around" or something like that?
It's the whims of emotion - in the moment a person says it it can be quite sincere, as that's their genuine mood in that instance, but later on the mood passes and the effort involved in arranging something outweighs the desire.<p>In that sense it does communicate something: I like and have enjoyed your company in this moment.<p>Flippant of course, but not too dastardly.
That was the one I struggled the most with.<p>I generally mean social invitations sincerely, and expect that other people do too, but also my social anxiety leaves me somewhat relieved if we don't follow through.
> If you are the one to follow up, they'd join you.<p>I get this. I don't want to be imposing myself, and I want to give the person an out if they don't want to meet me.<p>But I also want them to know that I would be up for having a coffee.
The test doesn't follow the correct procedures for diagnosing autism and after a thorough reading of the DSM-5-TR I could find no mention of German a mental illness being and I challenge anyone to me wrong prove.
> German a mental illness <i>being</i><p>If your comment is an attempt to run the game directly in the HN comments, I'm going to guess "German" by the placement of your verb here. :)
Your grammar is wrong.
Anzeige raus!
(100%, 100%)
Are you German?
It's obvious Claude slop, a stupid meme for people who want to think they are special
Yeah, we all know that. Could it be that you're German or autistic?
Die tests must be 100% accurate and follow the best known clinical procedures. Humor is not optimal.
I think it's just a funny joke, I found myself chuckling.
Posting my result here in case you want to see the different results without redoing the test:<p><pre><code> German 47% - Autistic 47%
Wittgenstein was Austrian, which is close enough. He was also, by most accounts, someone whose relationship to social convention was at best functional and at worst a source of significant suffering to himself and everyone around him.
He rewrote philosophy twice. The first time by establishing what could be said with precision. The second time by dismantling the assumption that precision was the right goal in the first place. Both versions emerged from the same source: an absolute refusal to accept confusion as a resting state.
You have, apparently, both the cultural formation that produces systematic people and the neurological substrate that makes systematic thinking feel like breathing. This is either a significant advantage or an explanation for certain recurring difficulties in your life. Probably both.
Schopenhauer also fits here. So does Ramanujan, though he wasn't German. The category isn't German or autistic — it's people for whom the gap between how things are and how they ought to be is not an abstraction but a constant, low-grade irritation.
</code></pre>
Share blurb:<p><pre><code> I took the German or Autistic diagnostic. Result: Both. The Wittgenstein Result. I don't know whether to be proud or concerned. https://german.millermanschool.com/</code></pre>
I got the very same 47/47. What if it's always giving that?
Neither Somehow.<p>German 29%, Autistic 22%<p>¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Regarding punctuality I miss the option: “A moral obligation from my side, but I don’t care if others arrive late to an appointment with me”
There's a quote in the Count of Monte Cristo where Edmond explains punctuality something to the effect:<p>> Being early to an appointment is as rude as being late because you may be disturbing your host before they've taken all the efforts they require before your arrival<p>( VERY rough quote, the english translation is 100x more eloquent than my half-remembered version )<p>Edmond Dantès arrives exactly as the clock strikes the minute of his appointment no later and no earlier. I remember reading that when I was ~16 and it always seemed to make sense to me
I guess the Brazilian take on this would be:<p><i>"Being on time is rude because you may be disturbing your host before they’ve made all the preparations they need before your arrival. Being early would be an outrageous offense."</i><p>It always amazes me how Brazilians and Germans can be so different when it comes to punctuality and yet so similar when it comes to their love of bureaucracy (and devotion to soccer, for that matter).
I specifically give people a time somewhere in the middle of a window in which they could arrive that neither disturbs my preparations nor disturbs the schedule I've devised. Everything may not be exactly ready at the beginning of that window but any preparations left to do can be performed while socializing (finish making appetizers, for example).<p>It also depends on who my guests are. If I know they are consistently late, I give them an earlier time. If they are always early, I give them a later time.<p>My grandfather was overly punctual. He'd show up 30-60mins early for dinner and my mom hated it. My mom loves hosting people but she can't do that while she's blowdrying her hair or helping her children get ready. So she would tell him a different time than everyone else coming over so he'd show up when everyone and everything was ready.
In the Brazilian case, it is not so much "love of bureaucracy" but rather "bureaucracy as a protection against private capture of public goods and services".
This is the Swiss stance.
The test doesn't have masochist as result
it's called putting yourself to higher standards then you think are reasonable to force random 3rd parties too even through you would appreciate it if they also had similar high standards<p>has nothing to do with masochism but all with realizing that you live in a society and can't just force your preferred social norms unilaterally on other, even if you can nudge people in a direction, in hope society will change in the future
It depends. If I invite you to my house, I don't really care unless you're too early or _very_ late.<p>If we are to meet in public - like restaurant - I don't want to awkwardly wait 15 minutes or more. At the very least, early notice is an obligation.
My dearest childhood friend is half Italian, allegedly.<p>However, his woeful time-keeping is so poor that we began to suspect that he was indeed simply from another planet... with a longer day.
Yeah that's also how I work: be strict to yourself, indulgent to other, I feel this is the best strategy to get along. Obviously, the downside is the tragedy of the commons: the few bad people abusing the leniency of the rest and getting away with it, like people showing up late because "they hate waiting".
I fully agree with this sentiment. I set a high standard for my punctuality but I don't care if you're late.
I just silently judge you.
"I don't care I just silently judge you" ... kinda sounds like you care. ;)
Unless I care about the meeting it gives me an easy way out. More than 5 minutes late in that case is "let's try it again another time"
"I don't care if you're late" versus "I just silently judge you".<p>Which one is it?
Not OP but my general approach is similar: "I see it as wrong but do not feel entitled to impose my standards on others".
I don't show you that I care would probably be more accurate.
Perhaps he's a German expat who has absorbed the Parisian attitude<p><i>Watch me not care</i>
To me it lacks the option “moral obligation but only hold accountable people who live alone”
Why? Bathroom queues or things like that? I live alone but am almost always late. A few weeks ago I was late to the airport for a flight by a couple of hours. Yesterday I was late to work, I was commuting by car when an officer thought of stopping me and do some checks for around 10-15 minutes. It does feel like I'm cursed or something. It happens way too often, but almost always feels as if it's completely outside my control.<p>For instance (and maybe this is embarrassing ...), I was late to the airport because the day before I went a bit later to bed than planned, so I overslept my alarm a bit, but still had plenty of breathing room. So I proceed, with the car. As it happens, I live in a country, let's say NL, and the airport was in BE. It also happens that fuel is significantly cheaper in BE than in NL (over 25% cheaper at the time). I'm also quite precise about fuel consumption.<p>As it happens, speed limit in NL is 100km/h during the day, but 130 during the night. I was still well within the high speed section during those very early moments of dawn. But I normally only ride my car during the day. So I know intimately how much fuel I'm using. So I calculate things ,with a lot of safety margins, to optimize fueling costs, by reaching BE with not a lot of fuel. However, as I was a bit underslept. Normally I know exactly how many km I can do after the low fuel indicator comes on. I of course anticipated this would be lower at 130/h rather than 100/h, but somehow, my calculations were a bit off. I ran out of fuel on the highway, well inside BE, but some 2km short of the gas station.<p>Not the best of times, as you can imagine. I was starting to panic a bit, thinking of eventual costs, I don't know the exact law in BE, if I have to pay someone to tow me, it would cost probably hundreds of time more than the potential savings. But somehow, the place where the car stopped was in a location under a bridge, where I could actually get off the emergency lane, so in a very protected spot. Must have been 5AM at the time, I proceed to walk towards the first exit, grabbing a plastic bottle from the ground. After about 800m i manage to get off the highway, to that first settlement, and not long after, a very nice gentlemen takes me to the gas station. I discovered, stupefied, that the station only sells truck diesel. I walk a few minutes to the next one. Same story. I keep walking until I finally find one selling petrol, and a very nice lady, after explaining her my situation, agrees to take me to my car on the highway, which was 1-2km away. I do pay her for her trouble.<p>Now, this whole incident only took about an hour, so I'm still sort of on track. But now it's starting to be early morning, and some of the worst traffic jams I've encountered. Basically the trip takes over 90 minutes more than originally estimated. I buy another plane ticket for another plane later that day and still end up not that badly, but ... yeah.
Hence the whole "If you're on time, you're late". Everywhere I go, has a 10-15 minute buffer, just in case of stuff like that. I end up early to 90% of the things I go to, on time to 5% (really "slightly late") and maybe late once every three years. Can't remember the last time I was ever late really, and it does bother me a lot if I am.
Could you leave earlier to account for the things that feel outside of your control?
I could in theory. But inside, it often feels that I'm doing everything as early as possible. Just that I'm overwhelmed. I also don't value being on time too much. I was recently late to a date of sorts, 10-15 minutes, which I think is a big reason why she didn't want to continue anything. It's never on purpose. It just happens. If I'm tired, I leave bed as soon as I can, but it's always a cost benefit analysis, always a decision being made. I may decide that those few minutes of extra rest are more valuable than being on time. If it's a person who I think deserves that punctuality from me, then I will go the extra mile of course.
Occasionally things will happen that you can't account for. I agree.<p>But from my perspective, the added example story was somewhat in your control. You just optimized for the wrong things. Of course this is easier in hindsight too.<p>Had you not run out of fuel, would you have missed the traffic too?<p>My fuel tank is always full. I fill it when it gets about 1/2 empty so that I am not caught stranded because I never know what will happen. Sometimes I get fuel even though I can make it, because what if something goes wrong?
Habits die hard. I have seen highways close for hours to days after an accident or snow storm. If you're stuck there is no where to go.
It's likely I would have missed the traffic jams had I not had the fuel incident, since this was 5AM, roads were empty at the time.<p>And yes, everything is under our control and nothing is. It's a matter of perspective. Everyone prioritizes, since we have limited time. We choose what we do with that time. Just that, some people, sometimes me included, have such a time debt that sucks their time that it spills into their "obligations".<p>As for optimizing for the wrong things, this is also to some degree outside control. I obviously realize on a rational level why it's "suboptimal", penny-wise and pound foolish. But change requires effort and time. Which are sometimes used up in other more urgent endeavours.
Considering the site we are, treat your effort/time debt as tech debt.<p>You appear to be past the point where it's beneficial, and should focus on reducing it to improve your life. Granted this is easily stated when I have no real context.
I agree but the thing is, how does one decide for the time that it might take for things which are outside of control, by definition, I am not sure of how long it might take.<p>And also, if we have a very long margin of time, then does the 0.01% you might be late somewhere really justify something like this.<p>Obviously it depends on the context, but personally, things just happen in life and its hard to take into factor how many things are and are not in my control.
> It happens way too often, but almost always feels as if it's completely outside my control.<p>Same thing happens to my partner. They're just fundamentally bad at estimating time and constantly do things that maximize their probability of being late.<p>Your story for example, almost nothing was outside your control.
TLDR but guessing from the length of your comment, it really is about respecting other people‘s time
"A moral obligation from my side, but I prefer if others don't come to an appointment with me"
I lived in Germany for 10+ years, so unsurprisingly got Both (40/62) as result, although it was slightly frustrating sometimes to pick between answers where none really fit precisely (which in itself is probably a sign too, lol)
I never lived in Germany, but live in Spain since more than 10 years, also got 40%/67% German/Autistic. And yes, very fun to live in a society with the personal rule of "being on time is being late" when everyone else is basically "late doesn't exists as a concept". I do enjoy pretty much everything else though :)
56/31. I'm really unsatisfied with the choices for Question 15, "The real problem with the world is...". None of them seem to capture "not everyone is playing by the same rules"
I am German, not autistic.<p>This confuses me as I have never been to Germany and do not speak German.<p>But rules are rules.
Having lived in Germany and experienced the wonderful Deutche Bahn, I wouldn't really associate punctuality with being German.
Alas, the tendency to overgeneralize from isolated samples over whole populations is universally human.
The Deutsche Bahn rather cancel trains completely instead of them being late - which also says something.
People love to parrot this, but it's not true and makes no sense for them to try and game the system this way. The mandatory compensation and bad press from cancelled trains is way more costly on them than having poor punctuality statistics.<p>The reason that a late train can sometimes be cancelled is to try and stop a cascade of delays from happening. Tracks only have so much capacity, and if train gets delayed into a time-frame that is highly congested, trying to fit the delayed train into that time-frame will result in delaying other trains, which could then cause further problems down the lines and throw the entire network out of order.<p>They accept a certain number of cascading delays like this, but sometimes it's just known that a certain delayed train will just be too disruptive to the network, so they're forced to just cancel a train to try and save the network's stability.
By the time a train is delayed enough to be canceled the mandatory compensation applies anyway, and I'm not sure how much DB cares about bad press.<p>I can see the cancellations as a means of stopping a cascade of delays, but it's also true that doing so means the train won't count in the delay statistics for the remaining stops. If DB doesn't want people to accuse them of gaming the statistics, perhaps they should calculate said statistics in a way that doesn't directly benefit them when they inconvenience their delayed passengers even more?
This. Put another way, if it's harder to solve the problem than the statistic, then change the statistics.<p>Obvious in many ways once you've lived there
Sometimes, the Deutsche Bahn is so late, that it's early. Wrapping around. The previous train in the schedule sometimes was so late, that it was just a bit before the next one was supposed to depart. So the next one is cancelled or delayed. I experienced this a few times. But with the cheap Deutschland Ticket, I couldn't really complain at the time. Tho, Arnhem to Hamburg, even 8h late, was not the most enjoyable of experiences (again, Deutchland Ticket, around 2023 IIRC. so no IC trains, which didn't suffer to the same degree).
Most of the German stereotypes are not just untrue, reality is actually the opposite. Germans are not efficient as an example, they love layers of formality and documentation for its own shake at the cost of getting stuff done.
As a German, after encountering Russian bureaucracy once, I commented to my wife that the main difference between Russian and German bureaucracy is that in Russia at least you can pay your way out.
As a student of German (80 on DuoLingo) I'm fascinated by the definite articles.<p>If we're going to manage gender and case across nouns appearing in sentences, why not make them more distinct, please?<p>We've got 'die' owning far too much real estate here, in my opinion.
It's also not as clean as the stereotypes would suggest.
>"Having lived in Germany and experienced the wonderful Deutche Bahn, I wouldn't really associate punctuality with being German."<p>This is relative. In Germany, people complain when the train is late. Everywhere else, the train is just late.
> In Germany, people complain when the train is late. Everywhere else, the train is just late.<p>You think people don't complain when the train is late in other countries? That's hardly a uniquely German thing
IIRC DB currently has a worse punctuality record than the UK rail network. That takes some doing.
The Swiss nervously check the time when a train is 2-3 minutes late. When a train is late, the situation is basically on the brink of a national emergency.
I am currently living abroad, but I come from northern Italy. Rest assured that we complain a lot about our trains being late.
I mean I've regularly seen trains in germany arriving AFTER the next train. Statistically they are worse than pretty much any european country.<p>And outside of trains, my german friends run the gamut of being always on time to systematically being 30 minutes late. Don't really see much of a correlation between being German and punctual.<p>Japan on the other hand I do associate with punctuality, when I worked there I was made to sit in the seiza postion for the m9rniny meeting if I was late by even 3 minutes. My friends there were overwhelmingly ontime except (and proving my point) for a German coworker I had there :)
This is not true, people complain a lot in France when the trains are late.
Only 31% German despite being German. Maybe I'm not German after all.
Sometimes you're born in the "wrong country". My life was essentially a mess until I moved across the continent to a country that much better follows what I personally want out of life, then suddenly a bunch of seemingly unrelated issues just solved themselves.
58% German / 27% Autistic<p>As an Austrian I am not sure how to feel about that
As a Viennese, I missed appropriate options, like rules and their mutual negotiability by lateral maneuvers (AKA dissimulation) and a general sense for disgruntledness. Moreover, smalltalk as the core of any negotiations (which should be understood more as mundane paperwork after the fact) isn't even mentioned! Now I do need some coffee, for real. ;-)
Makes sense to me. As an Italian currently in Austria, you are close to being German, without being one fully.
Secret Piefke :-)
More like "31% German according to stereotypes about Germans formed by some random foreigner who read some 19th century German philosophy texts, and has an affinity for Russian neo-fascis"
I feel you ... only got 44%.
Same here, 27%, I am disappoint (although maybe the test doesn't account for East-German-ness)
There's an interesting spectrum of reactions here. Maybe the real test is peoples' reactions to the test...
40/40 - nailed it (not actually German though)<p>“The category isn't German or autistic — it's people for whom the gap between how things are and how they ought to be is not an abstraction but a constant, low-grade irritation.”
As a member of the German diaspora (who has faced the autistic allegations his whole life) who grew up with, and was heavily influenced by, his Oma, this is immensely reassuring.
I took the German or Autistic diagnostic and scored Neither. I am apparently the control group.
Having lived in Germany, the strongest cultural conflict I felt was inflexibility of plans.<p>The German way is to plan something very meticulously and the to follow through with the plan no matter what.<p>I am however of the persuasion of not planning too much beforehand especially when the input is lacking. But also to be flexible and reactive during execution.
I got 36% German, 33% Autistic.<p>I didn't think I was <i>that</i> normal, but here we are.
I scored Neither and received a congratulation for being the control group
60% german, 40% autistic. Seems fair since I'm german and work in IT.
The rules question did not have an answer I liked tho.
Frustratingly, many of the questions have multiple answers that can apply simultaneously! (You may like to guess my result.)
I always thought I had learned to successfully mask as one of my compatriots, but the test ruthlessly exposes me as 80% Autistic / 20% German.<p>The test is broken, if you ask me.
The test says that I'm 66% German. As a German I'm not really sure how to interpret that :-)
"Shut up and follow directions unless you know better." is a phrase I think translates very well in all languages. Not German. Not Autism. Just harsh feedback for people that need to hear it once in awhile. Mostly management types.
Too many people think they know better. You're not allowed to think you know better unless you're able to put yourself in the position to be the one to write the directions.<p>You know how many conversations I have with people who are mad about a problem, and I tell them that's the reason we have a policy they didn't follow, and then they say they should tell people that that's the reason for the policy, and then I tell them they do explain it, right where the policy is written. Oh my God, you didn't read the policies before you did this, did you!? What else did you miss!?
Hmm, sounds close to "shut up and mind your own business because sure I know better" so I'm keen to upvote it.
44% German. Possible. I’m not German, but I’m from nearby and I do have a German surname.<p>„ Your patterns are cultural, not neurological.” - that’s for sure. My neurological ones were so terrible I had to resort outer sources.
I got "the Wittgenstein result", which I guess makes sense as I used to live down the street from his childhood home.
I'm neither apparently, which I guess is a relief? Some of the questions I felt didn't have an answer I would select, like the inner monologue one. I generally don't have an inner monologue as I understand it described by people who do. Also, there's way more wrong with the world than those four answers.
Didn't suspect getting both is an option
I also got both. I'm Norwegian, so culturally half-German seems relatively reasonable. And the autism part I think more than one person who have met me have suspected (no diagnosis, and probably wouldn't get diagnosed <i>now</i>, because I've had a few decades of getting good at masking quite a few things I know would've shown up on an assessment)
I can verify this. I am autistic and german. The tests also said I am both.
You are the true edge case of this test :) I got both as well, which I interpret as decent middle ground which is what I expected, for the record I’m neither.
I am neither, yet the test said I'm both. I guess I need to go to the embassy and start collecting free healthcare benefits for my diagnosis.
I guess I am an autistic atypical german. (had 29, 69)
Per the guide, it's not zero sum.<p><i>> Scores are independent — they don't need to add up to 100%.</i>
Same
This test is good and also I'm not sure it's meant to be funny, but it is <i>very</i> funny.
Feature request: a worldle style share button. E.g.
42%(DE emoji) 20%(Puzzle emoji)<p>Update: I scrolled down. Your share button is pretty good!
47% German, 20% autistic. Too German for my taste, but I have a couple of very German behaviors even though I am Spanish.
Turns out, I'm more autistic than German. But it should have been expected, as the latter isn't my nationality.
78% autistic, 16% German. My ancestry is Dutch which as someone who grew up in the UK feels about 16% German.
It told me I was both German and Autistic?<p>Completely wrong! I am neither German <i>nor</i> Autistic!
Honestly, I really want to know what the German options are and the autistic options are.
58% German
49% Autistic<p>As a German the first part I can follow. Autistic was a bit of a surprise.
German but probably not autistic. I shall go and celebrate with some Dunkerbier.
I am 40% German, 40% Autistic.<p>Will be gone a while while I look for the other 20%.
I got 20% autistic, 80% Irish?
I am German but the test says I'm neither (31%/36%). I will now think about this result for a few days, if not weeks.....
> I took the German or Autistic diagnostic. Result: Both. The Wittgenstein Result. I don't know whether to be proud or concerned.<p>It was 47% 47%. AMA!! I've got stories man, just give me a specific prompt. I can also tell stories about my PhD advisor (100% german, 70% autistic).
YOUR RESULT<p>Both<p>The Wittgenstein Result<p>GERMAN 49%<p>AUTISTIC 40%<p>Been once to Germany, maybe twice. Can't vouch the other.
AI slop, absolutely meaningless, don't take it seriously.<p>Btw I tested neither, 30% each; "the controll group". So I am formally authorized to criticise the page as a perfectly normal person.
I think the archetype does not work well. For instance, people in Bavaria are very different to people in the northern areas of Germany. This includes the language too. The first question was about punctuality; I don't think all germans are always on time, it totally depends on many factors, including age. Perhaps decades ago this was accurate, but nowadays it feels to me as if people living in larger cities, are often much more alike to one another. And I think this trend will continue.<p>Back in the 1990s I was in Hong Kong. The city was epic, cool and alien. Today I feel I could live there even without speaking cantonese (I understand the top-down control via Beijing being a huge problem; I refer to what a city may look like in 2026 and beyond though from a theoretical point of view. Naturally knowing the language helps insanely, but english works as a substitute in many modern areas, even in non-english speaking countries).
Hogwash, this says I'm German but "probably not autistic."
I'm not sure how I feel about this, but I liked the writing:<p>> You are difficult to work with in the ways all serious people are difficult to work with. This is not a diagnosis. It is a compliment.
On being interrupted, "It's difficult to describe. Something like a physical sensation."<p>This is extremely relatable. I'm pretty confident that this physical sensation is related to my (rather severely) limited working memory, which I have to carefully manage at maximum capacity and which is catastrophically overwhelmed by some interruptions. A token interruption ("hey, do you have a sec"?) Doesn't tend to cause the sensation, but an interruption that contains data ("I called Greg about the plan for Wednesday and he said that Susan said...") is psychologically painful and even enraging in an oddly visceral sort of way.
Am I the only one who got "neither"?
Also got neither. I’m Irish but have lived a long time in Austria now. The punctuality thing is common with Germans. They have a different approach to rules here I think.
I'm also neither. But I'm also very good at lying to myself, so who knows?
(not me)
Nope. 31% German, 27% Autistic.
64% autistic
31% German<p>disappointed
Thanks chatgpt