5 comments

  • cjrp2 hours ago
    ATC recording on <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.liveatc.net&#x2F;recordings.php" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.liveatc.net&#x2F;recordings.php</a> Fire truck was cleared to cross and then told to stop. I&#x27;m not sure if they were the only controller working at the time, they continued working after the incident which seems unusual; my understanding is normally they&#x27;d be relieved by another controller.
    • embedding-shape8 minutes ago
      &gt; I&#x27;m not sure if they were the only controller working at the time, they continued working after the incident which seems unusual; my understanding is normally they&#x27;d be relieved by another controller<p>I remember late last year, couple of months ago, US ATC controllers were without pay but forced to work anyways (similar to TSA I suppose, although I don&#x27;t think they were forced, but volunteered to work without salary), is that still the situation? Couldn&#x27;t find any updates about that the situation been resolved, nor any updates that it&#x27;s ongoing, if so though it feels like it&#x27;d be related to the amount of available controllers.
    • brownieeee1 hour ago
      They were indeed the only controller, working both ground and tower frequencies.
      • the_mitsuhiko5 minutes ago
        Which, as a non informed person but someone who needs to travel by plane, sounds absolutely insane. Was it always possible to staff that with a single person or is that a result of understaffing?
  • cmiles82 hours ago
    Emergency vehicles were en route to another emergency in progress on the other runway. Sadly it sounds like a fire truck was cleared to cross the active runway moments before the CRJ landed. By the time the controller realized that mistake it was too late.
    • _moof2 hours ago
      I&#x27;m very, very curious about whether the ARFF crew visually cleared the runway and final before crossing the hold short line. It&#x27;s standard procedure for flight crew to do this, specifically to mitigate the risk of ATC errors.
      • cmiles80 minutes ago
        Yes ARFF should still look before crossing, but the weather wasn’t great with limited visibility and thus even if they looked it’s possible they didn’t see anything.
      • gortok49 minutes ago
        Reports are there were fog and rain at La Guardia at the time of the incident. They were on a short final, and it’s entirely possible they were not visible to the fire truck’s crew.
      • bombcar1 hour ago
        At night with multiple runways it can be very hard to see a plane on final.<p>Still, I&#x27;m always hesitant to cross an active runway.
      • PierceJoy1 hour ago
        I mean, isn&#x27;t it obvious that they didn&#x27;t?
        • wat100001 hour ago
          It’s obvious that either they didn’t, or they did but they didn’t see the plane. We don’t know which.
  • throw0101d1 hour ago
    &quot;Plane and ground vehicle collide at New York&#x27;s LaGuardia airport halting flights&quot;:<p>* <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=47486386">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=47486386</a>
  • newsclues1 hour ago
    <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;x.com&#x2F;thenewarea51&#x2F;status&#x2F;2035926457394876837" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;x.com&#x2F;thenewarea51&#x2F;status&#x2F;2035926457394876837</a><p>ATC audio<p>make a mistake, recognize it, and then have to continue on your job, knowing you likely just killed people, because if you don&#x27;t others will die.<p>The weight of some jobs is immense, and our civilization relies upon workers to shoulder the burden everyday.
    • wat100001 hour ago
      And these guys are tremendously overworked because the government can’t get its shit together to hire enough people to staff at appropriate levels.
      • callmeal1 hour ago
        &quot;Government&quot;? Let&#x27;s call it what it is. ITYM &quot;Republicans&quot;.
        • tatersolid56 minutes ago
          The shortage of ATC staff dates back to the Clinton Administration. It’s just hard to attract people into a 5+ year training program for a very stressful job where you might get bounced near the end with no payout and no transferrable job skills.
          • lesuorac52 minutes ago
            I think you mean Reagan. He removed the union for the ATC not Clinton.<p>Honestly, you can generally just blame Reagan for about anything. A presidency about weaking labor, strengthening Iran, and ballooning the deficit is uh never going to leave good traces.
          • achr248 minutes ago
            No the shortage goes back to Regan when their justified strike was busted. It ended the PATCO “union” and was a negative turning point for labour unions in general.
        • jasonlotito39 minutes ago
          Yes. Reagan was a Republican.
  • renewiltord53 minutes ago
    Are the increased number of air incidents since Dec 2024 reflective of anything real or is it more attention on something? Brigida v. USDOT comes to mind but doesn&#x27;t seem relevant. I&#x27;m sure we could all construct a chain of &quot;this thing happened that caused that which caused this&quot; and so on, but I&#x27;m curious if someone has done the effort to see whether such a chain is defensible.<p>Also, did the pilots die in the collision or in some sort of aftermath? The cockpit looks absolutely smashed.